AltProtein VietnamAlternative protein in VietnamA supply-side scoping study · Version 1.0

Chapter 28Part V: What should be done?

28. Moves that pay off in any 2050

10 min readHow to read the evidence
On this page
  1. 28.1 Seven no-regret moves
  2. 28.2 Six options: cheap to hold
  3. 28.3 Two bets, each with a trigger
  4. 28.4 One hedge
  5. 28.5 Sequencing: the first three years
  6. 28.6 By actor: the first move
  7. 28.7 What we could not resolve

In brief

  • A scenario set is useful only if it changes what people do today. We tested 16 moves against the four 2050 worlds of Scenarios 2050.
  • Seven are no-regret moves that pay off whatever happens. Most are public goods, and most can start in 2026 to 2028 at modest cost.
  • Six are options: cheap to hold now, valuable in some worlds.
  • Two are bets that should wait for named signposts. One is a hedge against the bad worlds.
  • The most urgent move is a new-food route in the Food Safety Law and its decree, in 2026 to 2027.

28.1 Seven no-regret moves

MoveWhat it involvesLead actorsStart byWhy it pays off everywhere
RM-01 Publish a national protein balanceA yearly balance of the protein people eat, by food, source and origin, with the imported feed behind itAgriculture ministry; statistics office; National Institute of Nutrition2028Every foreign target we tracked rests on a statistic2,3Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.
RM-03 New-food route with deadlinesA new-food procedure with deadlines and reliance on trusted regulators, including a safety lane for cultivated foodHealth ministry; agriculture ministry2027 to 2028Needed to import approved ingredients as well as make them; the law window is open now4,5,6,7Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.
RM-04 Shared food-grade pilot capacity10,000 to 30,000 L of open, food-grade pilot fermentation, with taste and safety testingScience ministry; Ho Chi Minh City; universities; development banks2030Rivals have it (Thailand has two 15,000 L tanks); we found none open in Vietnam8,9,10,11Evidence: evidence from a comparable country, with the transfer stated (VN-adjacent); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.
RM-05 Protein-quality laboratory and open price seriesAccredited protein-quality and safety testing; a public price series for protein ingredients, including domestic bean pricesScience ministry; agriculture ministry; a university2028Imports and domestic products need the same checks; no Vietnamese laboratory offers digestibility tests12,13,14,15,16,17Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.
RM-06 Residue-carbon rules and a by-product atlasMapped volumes of cassava pulp, straw, okara and brewery streams; collection contracts; food-safety rules for food-grade side streamsAgriculture ministry; provinces; industry2028Rice straw must be fully collected on 1 million ha by 203018,19Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.
RM-08 Climate-proof sitingRaised sites and surface water in the Mekong Delta; plants designed for warm cooling waterProvinces; investors2027The delta sinks about 1.1 cm a year, so coastal plants built after 2035 face flood risk in their lifetime (our inference)20,21,22Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part. Forward-looking: projection, a published model result or an official target.
RM-09 Process-engineering skillsTwo tracks: a master's for senior engineers, and operator training through industry ministry colleges and the national food research institute; plus a product challenge labEducation, industry and science ministries; universities; industry2027Senior biotech talent is the named bottleneck; no alternative-protein or industrial fermentation course exists23,24,25,26Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.

7 of 21 moves

No-regret moves for 2026 to 2030

2026 assessmentOur calculationEvidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); low confidence: a single claim, press, company marketing or our derivation from weak inputs. Forward-looking: estimate, our own calculation from stated assumptions.

Context and sources

A national protein balance; a new-food route with deadlines; shared food-grade pilot capacity; a protein-quality laboratory and price series; residue-carbon rules and a by-product atlas; climate-proof siting; process-engineering skills. Five feed moves tested earlier are no longer recommended. Our judgement.1,27

The protein balance (RM-01) has a first version. We built one from FAO food balance sheets (Why Vietnam, section 1.1). It shows that 19% to 23% of the protein supply was imported food in 2023. Counting feed, 61% to 71% of animal protein rested on imports (our calculation)28,29,30Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); low confidence: a single claim, press, company marketing or our derivation from weak inputs.. We found none published by a Vietnamese agencyEvidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.. A national version would also fix weak FAO figures, such as eggs and milk. Its method matches Europe's31,32Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); high confidence: a primary source was read..

It has an official hook. The food-security resolution to 2030 has no import or protein indicator33Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); high confidence: a primary source was read.. But the agriculture ministry's 2026 plan asks to "step by step reduce import dependence"34Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); high confidence: a primary source was read.. A protein balance would let it measure that. The headline indicator should be the share of protein eaten that is made from domestic inputs, by where the inputs come from, not where processing happens (our judgement)Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); low confidence: a single claim, press, company marketing or our derivation from weak inputs. Forward-looking: estimate, our own calculation from stated assumptions..

Skills (RM-09) has two tracks and a product lab.

  • Senior engineers. A 2025 national programme funds 100 talent master's programmes, and universities are asked to pair biotechnology with application fields35,36Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.. A "biotechnology plus food process engineering" master's fits (our suggestion).
  • Operators. That programme has no operator track35Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.. The industry ministry runs the food colleges and the national food research institute, which has a fermentation department37,38Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.. So it should lead.
  • The constraint is equipment, not fees. A hands-on US fermentation course costs about USD 3,100; a first cohort of 20 would cost about USD 62,000 in fees (our calculation)39Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); low confidence: a single claim, press, company marketing or our derivation from weak inputs. Forward-looking: estimate, our own calculation from stated assumptions.. But shared pilot capacity comes only by 2030, so early training must use industrial tanks or go abroad.
  • A teaching capstone on the shared line, once it exists, would also give it steady users40Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); high confidence: a primary source was read..
  • A product challenge lab: a one-semester course where student teams solve problems set and part-funded by Vietnamese buyers. Berkeley ran such classes for seven years, producing at least three startups41,42,43,44,45,46Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.. Drop it if no firm sets a problem in the first cycle.

The public goods fold in. The new-food procedure (P1) becomes RM-03. The protein-quality laboratory (P4) and price series (P6) become RM-05. The by-product atlas (P5) becomes RM-06 (Policy options).

28.2 Six options: cheap to hold

MoveWhat it involvesPays off most inStart byEvidence
RM-10 Reserve hub sitesName food-fermentation hubs in the national biotechnology cluster plan (due December 2026) and in provincial high-tech farm zonesA, C2026 to 2027The map is still blank; provinces can now create such zones47,48,49Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.
RM-11 Small permanent protein-innovation fundUSD 5 to 15 M a year for food-protein innovation, reviewed each five-year planA, C; useful in all2027Denmark, Germany and Canada spend similar sums a year50,51,52Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.
RM-12 Cheap-finance windowDevelopment-bank co-finance and guarantees for first fermentation plants (T4, T5 scale), with a buyer's agreement to take the output; ready when a signpost tripsC, D2028Cutting the cost of capital from 12% to 9% does as much as the cost learning expected by 2030 (our calculation)Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); low confidence: a single claim, press, company marketing or our derivation from weak inputs. Forward-looking: estimate, our own calculation from stated assumptions.
RM-13 Join regional approval and statistics networksTake part in Southeast Asian reliance work and the EU-style protein balance methodA, C2027Reliance is how smaller regulators keep paceEvidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); low confidence: a single claim, press, company marketing or our derivation from weak inputs.; the EU is building such balances2Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.
RM-14 Seed research on cultivated seafood and gas fermentationSmall programmes with foreign partners on Vietnamese species; open flavour profiles of farmed fishA, C2028Vietnam has 2 of 494 gas-fermentation papers53Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); high confidence: a primary source was read.; cell lines exist abroad for grouper and seabass54,55Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); low confidence: a single claim, press, company marketing or our derivation from weak inputs.
RM-15 Clear rules for second-hand fermentation equipmentCustoms and tax treatment; a register of used tanks, 2027 to 2030C2027One US firm's tanks sold for a fraction of their cost56,57,58Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.

The innovation fund (RM-11) is large by Vietnamese standards: half to one and a half times everything the national science foundation approved for new projects in 2023 (our calculation)59Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.. A first step would be one themed research call of about USD 0.35 million (Knowledge and talent)Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part. Forward-looking: estimate, our own calculation from stated assumptions..

The cheap-finance window (RM-12) is for fermentation plants, not textured soy. Existing loan guarantees and leases already cover a textured-protein line60,61,62,63Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); high confidence: a primary source was read.. The window matters at the scale of tens of millions of USD.

Seed research (RM-14) adds species and flavour. Asian seabass and grouper are farmed in Vietnam, and food-oriented cell lines exist abroad; catfish can serve as a cheap model species64,54,55,65,66Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); low confidence: a single claim, press, company marketing or our derivation from weak inputs.. An open flavour dataset for cooked catfish, tilapia and carp would serve makers of plant-based, blended and cultivated seafood. One research funder has asked for exactly such data67,68,69,70Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part..

12% to 9% capital charge does as much as the learning expected by 2030

Value of cheaper capital for fermentation protein

2026 inputsOur calculationEvidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); low confidence: a single claim, press, company marketing or our derivation from weak inputs. Forward-looking: estimate, our own calculation from stated assumptions.

Context and sources

Cutting the annual capital charge from 12% to 9% lowers the 2030 low-end cost of fungal biomass protein (feed-grade cost stack) to about USD 3,610 per t of protein with no learning at all, close to the central learning case in 2030 (USD 3,557 after two doublings of output). Our calculation (ecf_calc.py) on the chapter 9 cost stack.71,72,73,74,75,76,77

28.3 Two bets, each with a trigger

Each bet pays off in one world and loses money in others, so each waits for a trigger.

BetPays off inTrigger before scalingWhy wait
RM-18 Contract precision-fermentation plant for exportAA new-food route, a regional approval system or capacity outside China, and an anchor customerWorks today only for high-value proteins78Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.
RM-19 Sugar from rice strawCAn Asian straw plant above 80% of capacity for a full year (our threshold)Every Western commercial plant has shut; India's reached 62%79,80Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part.

A bet placed before its trigger trips is speculation, not policy.

28.4 One hedge

RM-21 Import monitoring and equal standards. Track the volumes and prices of protein-ingredient imports for food, including soybeans, and apply the same safety rules to imports and domestic products. No baseline series exists todayEvidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); low confidence: a single claim, press, company marketing or our derivation from weak inputs.. This limits the damage of dumping in worlds B and D without closing the market.

Soybean imports are concentrated: 89% came from Brazil and the US in 2025 (our calculation)81Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); high confidence: a primary source was read.. When the US briefly embargoed soybean exports in 1973, Japan responded by financing a new supply origin in Brazil82Evidence: global evidence, not specific to Vietnam (general); medium confidence: a reputable secondary source, or a primary source read in part..

Feed moves are retired, because feed is context only. Better feed efficiency would cut 2050 soybean meal need about twice as much as the alternative-protein scenario, but sits outside this study (Protein balance 2050)Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); low confidence: a single claim, press, company marketing or our derivation from weak inputs. Forward-looking: estimate, our own calculation from stated assumptions..

Moves across the four worlds

16 moves for protein people eat: no-regret, options, bets and a hedge; 2 = pays off strongly, 1 = partly, 0 = little

Moves across the four worldsHeatmap of 16 moves by four worlds. The seven no-regret moves pay off in all four. Options pay off mainly in the open-market worlds, the two bets in one open-market world each, and the hedge in the Chinese price-dominance worlds.0 little1 partly2 pays off stronglyA RegionalworkshopBComfortableprice-takerC Securitybuild-outD SqueezedimporterNo-regret moves (7)Publish a national protein balanceRM-01 Publish a national protein balance, A Regional workshop: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-01 Publish a national protein balance, B Comfortable price-taker: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-01 Publish a national protein balance, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-01 Publish a national protein balance, D Squeezed importer: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2New-food route with deadlinesRM-03 New-food route with deadlines, A Regional workshop: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-03 New-food route with deadlines, B Comfortable price-taker: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-03 New-food route with deadlines, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-03 New-food route with deadlines, D Squeezed importer: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2Shared food-grade pilot capacityRM-04 Shared food-grade pilot capacity, A Regional workshop: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-04 Shared food-grade pilot capacity, B Comfortable price-taker: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-04 Shared food-grade pilot capacity, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-04 Shared food-grade pilot capacity, D Squeezed importer: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2Protein-quality laboratory and open price seriesRM-05 Protein-quality laboratory and open price series, A Regional workshop: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-05 Protein-quality laboratory and open price series, B Comfortable price-taker: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-05 Protein-quality laboratory and open price series, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-05 Protein-quality laboratory and open price series, D Squeezed importer: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2Residue-carbon rules and a by-product atlasRM-06 Residue-carbon rules and a by-product atlas, A Regional workshop: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-06 Residue-carbon rules and a by-product atlas, B Comfortable price-taker: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-06 Residue-carbon rules and a by-product atlas, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-06 Residue-carbon rules and a by-product atlas, D Squeezed importer: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2Climate-proof siting for new plantsRM-08 Climate-proof siting for new plants, A Regional workshop: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-08 Climate-proof siting for new plants, B Comfortable price-taker: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-08 Climate-proof siting for new plants, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-08 Climate-proof siting for new plants, D Squeezed importer: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2Process-engineering skillsRM-09 Process-engineering skills, A Regional workshop: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-09 Process-engineering skills, B Comfortable price-taker: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-09 Process-engineering skills, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2RM-09 Process-engineering skills, D Squeezed importer: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: no-regret Pays off in: A; B; C; D2Options (6)Reserve hub sitesRM-10 Reserve hub sites, A Regional workshop: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C (D partly)2RM-10 Reserve hub sites, B Comfortable price-taker: 0 (little) Class: option Pays off in: A; C (D partly)0RM-10 Reserve hub sites, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C (D partly)2RM-10 Reserve hub sites, D Squeezed importer: 1 (partly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C (D partly)1Small permanent protein-innovation fundRM-11 Small permanent protein-innovation fund, A Regional workshop: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C (useful in all)2RM-11 Small permanent protein-innovation fund, B Comfortable price-taker: 1 (partly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C (useful in all)1RM-11 Small permanent protein-innovation fund, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C (useful in all)2RM-11 Small permanent protein-innovation fund, D Squeezed importer: 1 (partly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C (useful in all)1Concessional finance window for first plantsRM-12 Concessional finance window for first plants, A Regional workshop: 0 (little) Class: option Pays off in: C; D0RM-12 Concessional finance window for first plants, B Comfortable price-taker: 0 (little) Class: option Pays off in: C; D0RM-12 Concessional finance window for first plants, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: option Pays off in: C; D2RM-12 Concessional finance window for first plants, D Squeezed importer: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: option Pays off in: C; D2Join regional approval and statistics networksRM-13 Join regional approval and statistics networks, A Regional workshop: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C2RM-13 Join regional approval and statistics networks, B Comfortable price-taker: 1 (partly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C1RM-13 Join regional approval and statistics networks, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C2RM-13 Join regional approval and statistics networks, D Squeezed importer: 1 (partly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C1Seed research on cultivated seafood cells and gasfermentationRM-14 Seed research on cultivated seafood cells and gas fermentation, A Regional workshop: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C2RM-14 Seed research on cultivated seafood cells and gas fermentation, B Comfortable price-taker: 0 (little) Class: option Pays off in: A; C0RM-14 Seed research on cultivated seafood cells and gas fermentation, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: option Pays off in: A; C2RM-14 Seed research on cultivated seafood cells and gas fermentation, D Squeezed importer: 0 (little) Class: option Pays off in: A; C0Clear rules for second-hand fermentation equipmentRM-15 Clear rules for second-hand fermentation equipment, A Regional workshop: 1 (partly) Class: option Pays off in: C (A and D partly)1RM-15 Clear rules for second-hand fermentation equipment, B Comfortable price-taker: 0 (little) Class: option Pays off in: C (A and D partly)0RM-15 Clear rules for second-hand fermentation equipment, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: option Pays off in: C (A and D partly)2RM-15 Clear rules for second-hand fermentation equipment, D Squeezed importer: 1 (partly) Class: option Pays off in: C (A and D partly)1Bets (2)Contract precision-fermentation plant for exportRM-18 Contract precision-fermentation plant for export, A Regional workshop: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: bet Pays off in: A (C partly)2RM-18 Contract precision-fermentation plant for export, B Comfortable price-taker: 0 (little) Class: bet Pays off in: A (C partly)0RM-18 Contract precision-fermentation plant for export, C Security build-out: 1 (partly) Class: bet Pays off in: A (C partly)1RM-18 Contract precision-fermentation plant for export, D Squeezed importer: 0 (little) Class: bet Pays off in: A (C partly)0Cellulosic sugar from rice strawRM-19 Cellulosic sugar from rice straw, A Regional workshop: 1 (partly) Class: bet Pays off in: C (A partly)1RM-19 Cellulosic sugar from rice straw, B Comfortable price-taker: 0 (little) Class: bet Pays off in: C (A partly)0RM-19 Cellulosic sugar from rice straw, C Security build-out: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: bet Pays off in: C (A partly)2RM-19 Cellulosic sugar from rice straw, D Squeezed importer: 0 (little) Class: bet Pays off in: C (A partly)0Hedge (1)Import monitoring and equal standards for proteinimportsRM-21 Import monitoring and equal standards for protein imports, A Regional workshop: 1 (partly) Class: hedge Pays off in: B; D1RM-21 Import monitoring and equal standards for protein imports, B Comfortable price-taker: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: hedge Pays off in: B; D2RM-21 Import monitoring and equal standards for protein imports, C Security build-out: 1 (partly) Class: hedge Pays off in: B; D1RM-21 Import monitoring and equal standards for protein imports, D Squeezed importer: 2 (pays off strongly) Class: hedge Pays off in: B; D2

Our judgement of where each move pays off.

Sources1,27 Evidence: evidence about Vietnam (VN-direct); low confidence: a single claim, press, company marketing or our derivation from weak inputs.

Show the dataHide the data
Moves across the four worlds
MoveDescriptionClassA Regional workshopB Comfortable price-takerC Security build-outD Squeezed importerPays off in
RM-01Publish a national protein balanceno-regret2222A; B; C; D
RM-03New-food route with deadlinesno-regret2222A; B; C; D
RM-04Shared food-grade pilot capacityno-regret2222A; B; C; D
RM-05Protein-quality laboratory and open price seriesno-regret2222A; B; C; D
RM-06Residue-carbon rules and a by-product atlasno-regret2222A; B; C; D
RM-08Climate-proof siting for new plantsno-regret2222A; B; C; D
RM-09Process-engineering skillsno-regret2222A; B; C; D
RM-10Reserve hub sitesoption2021A; C (D partly)
RM-11Small permanent protein-innovation fundoption2121A; C (useful in all)
RM-12Concessional finance window for first plantsoption0022C; D
RM-13Join regional approval and statistics networksoption2121A; C
RM-14Seed research on cultivated seafood cells and gas fermentationoption2020A; C
RM-15Clear rules for second-hand fermentation equipmentoption1021C (A and D partly)
RM-18Contract precision-fermentation plant for exportbet2010A (C partly)
RM-19Cellulosic sugar from rice strawbet1020C (A partly)
RM-21Import monitoring and equal standards for protein importshedge1212B; D

28.5 Sequencing: the first three years

28.6 By actor: the first move

ActorFirst moveWhy first
Agriculture ministryCommission the national protein balanceThe statistic underpins every target
Health ministryA new-food procedure with deadlines and relianceThe one window that closes
Science ministry and Ho Chi Minh CityAn open food-grade pilot plantRivals already have one
Finance ministry and development banksA ready cheap-finance window for fermentation plantsCheaper capital does as much as the learning expected by 2030
Education and industry ministries, universitiesThe two skills tracksSkills take years, and the pilot line will need staff
Delta and cassava provincesRaised sites with surface water; residue-collection contractsLand and water decide 25-year plant economics
Feed millsShare anonymised feed dataThe protein balance needs it
InvestorsBack plays that hold in every world; hold bets with named triggersReturns depend on which world arrives
StartupsKoji and fungal foods (T9), or mung bean and rice protein for drinks (T10)Both hold in every world
ResearchersProcess know-how on local strains; the measurements behind the protein balanceFills the largest evidence gaps
International bodiesTechnical help on the protein balance and the review cycleA public good others can use

28.7 What we could not resolve

The questions that most decide which world is unfolding, and how big the moves should be:

  • whether any Vietnamese agency compiles a protein balance;
  • Vietnamese data on feed conversion and soybean meal use;
  • the purity and volume of carbon dioxide at named sites;
  • whether fermentation plants qualify for high-tech farm-zone incentives;
  • whether Vietnam's next climate plan will cap farm or livestock emissions for 2035;
  • which plants train fermentation operators, and whether any would take outside trainees.

Related: Scenarios 2050, Vision 2050, Policy options, Plays.

Sources cited on this page

Numbers in the text link here. Every source is also listed in the full source list. Full source list

  1. VIS-35Bock A.-K., Bontoux L.. Food safety and nutrition: how to prepare for a challenging future? New approaches for using scenarios for policy-making. 2017
  2. VIS-15European Commission. Action Plan for resilience, strategic autonomy and sustainability of the EU protein system. 7 Jul 2026
  3. VIS-13MAFF Japan. First Basic Plan for Food, Agriculture, and Rural Areas. May 2025
  4. REG-12GPC Gateway. Vietnam Notifies Draft Law Overhauling National Food Safety Framework. Aug 2026
  5. SLC-05FAO and WHO. Food safety aspects of cell-based food. 2023
  6. SLC-06Food Safety News (J. Whitworth). FAO and WHO consider the safety of cell-based food. 2023-04-06
  7. RGN-04Singapore Food Agency. SFA list of approved novel foods. 14 Aug 2026
  8. RGN-36EECi. Biorefinery Pilot Plant
  9. FTB-42BIOTEC (NSTDA, Thailand). The Launch of Bio Base Asia Pilot Plant (BBAPP) Joint Press Conference. 29 Mar 2022
  10. INF-02FIRI. FIRI, Food Production Pilot and Technology Transfer Center (FTET) page. undated
  11. INF-05HCMC Biotechnology Center, technology transfer services list. undated
  12. INF-03FIRI. FIRI, National Center for Food Analysis and Assessment (NACEFA) page. undated
  13. INF-10MOH. National Institute for Food Control (NIFC), home page
  14. INF-11Eurofins Vietnam, home page and food testing page
  15. INF-13QUATEST 3, home page (HQ; Dong Nai branch opened 14 Sep 2026)
  16. INF-14CASE (Center of Analytical Services and Experimentation HCMC), home page
  17. PPE-05The Protein Project. Towards a Legume Renaissance in Europe. 2026-02
  18. NTS-32Prime Minister. Quyết định 1490/QĐ-TTg, Đề án phát triển bền vững một triệu héc-ta chuyên canh lúa chất lượng cao và phát thải thấp vùng ĐBSCL đến năm 2030. 27 Nov 2023
  19. NGF-14European Union. Regulation (EC) No 767/2009 on the placing on the market and use of feed, consolidated text of 26 Dec 2018, Annex III Chapter 1 and footnote 9. 26 Dec 2018
  20. CLM-13Minderhoud P.S.J. et al.. Impacts of 25 years of groundwater extraction on subsidence in the Mekong delta, Vietnam. 2017
  21. CLM-14Minderhoud P.S.J., Middelkoop H., Erkens G., Stouthamer E.. Groundwater extraction may drown mega-delta: projections of extraction-induced subsidence and elevation of the Mekong delta for the 21st century. Dec 2019
  22. CLM-16Nguyen-Le D., Nguyen-Xuan T., Nguyen-Duy T., Trinh-Tuan L., Ngo-Duc T.. Assessment of future heat stress in Vietnam using physically based wet-bulb globe temperature and high-resolution downscaled projections. 2026
  23. ECF-39Ministry of Science and Technology (MOST) portal. Phát triển công nghệ sinh học: Bài toán nhân lực từ 'điểm nghẽn' đến động lực đột phá. 6 Apr 2026
  24. ECF-41Prime Minister. Quyết định 1002/QĐ-TTg năm 2025 phê duyệt Đề án đào tạo nguồn nhân lực phục vụ phát triển công nghệ cao giai đoạn 2025 đến 2035, định hướng đến năm 2045. 24 May 2025
  25. VCO-21GFI. Country: Vietnam - The alternative protein ecosystem
  26. SLW-14Food Industries Research Institute (MOIT). Đào tạo
  27. VIS-36Riera A., Duluins O., Antier C., Baret P.V.. Which types of quantitative foresight scenarios to frame the future of food systems? A review. 2025
  28. DIE-07FAO. FAOSTAT Food Balance Sheets. 2025-10-14
  29. MAC-01USDA FAS GAIN. Vietnam: Grain and Feed Annual, report VM2026-0012. 15 Apr 2026
  30. FS-23USDA FAS. Vietnam: Grain and Feed Annual. April 2026
  31. PPE-03The Protein Project. From dependency to diversity. 2026-06
  32. PPE-04The Protein Project. From dependency to diversity: Technical Appendix. 2026-06
  33. SEC-01Chính phủ (Government of Viet Nam). Nghị quyết 34/NQ-CP về bảo đảm an ninh lương thực quốc gia đến năm 2030. 2021-03-25
  34. SEC-02Bộ Nông nghiệp và Môi trường. Đánh giá tình hình thực hiện năm 2025 và kế hoạch phát triển ngành Nông nghiệp và Môi trường năm 2026. 2025-08-26
  35. SLW-07Tạp chí Công Thương (MOIT magazine). Phê duyệt Đề án đào tạo nguồn nhân lực phục vụ phát triển công nghệ cao. 2025-05-26
  36. SLW-08Ministry of Education and Training (MOET). Công văn 5695/BGDĐT-GDĐH 2025 triển khai Đề án đào tạo nhân lực công nghệ cao 2025 đến 2035. 2025-09-17
  37. SLW-17Ministry of Industry and Trade (MOIT). Trường Cao đẳng Công nghiệp Thực phẩm
  38. INF-01FIRI, MOIT. Food Industries Research Institute (Viện Công nghiệp Thực phẩm), home page (centres and departments). undated
  39. SLW-09NC State University BTEC. Fermentation Engineering. 2026
  40. AML-32College of Chemistry, UC Berkeley. Bioprocess Engineering Program Description
  41. AML-21Sutardja Center for Entrepreneurship and Technology, UC Berkeley. Challenge Labs
  42. AML-22University of California, Berkeley. UC Berkeley Class Search: INDENG 185 and ENGIN 183C sections, Fall 2019 to Spring 2024. 2019 to 2024
  43. AML-11Alt: Meat Lab, Sutardja Center for Entrepreneurship and Technology (SCET), UC Berkeley. SCET-born startup Terramino Foods receives $4.25 million in seed funding. 2018-07-24
  44. AML-13Alt: Meat Lab, Sutardja Center for Entrepreneurship and Technology (SCET), UC Berkeley. Alt: Meat Alumni Startup Impact Tuna. 2023-03-10
  45. AML-15Sutardja Center for Entrepreneurship and Technology, UC Berkeley. Uncracked profile: a values-led startup takes on seafood sustainability. 2023-06-07
  46. AML-33Tap chi Cong Thuong. FID 2025: Hanh trinh uom mam sang tao va thuc day cong nghe thuc pham ben vung. 2025-12-15
  47. HUB-09Ministry of Science and Technology portal. Công nghiệp sinh học mở rộng dư địa đóng góp cho nông nghiệp và môi trường. 21 Aug 2026
  48. HUB-26Government. Nghị định 263/2026/NĐ-CP về khu nông nghiệp ứng dụng công nghệ cao. 1 Jul 2026
  49. NTS-37Báo Chính phủ. Chỉ thị của Thủ tướng Chính phủ về việc tập trung phát triển, ứng dụng hiệu quả công nghệ sinh học thành ngành kinh tế - kỹ thuật quan trọng. 21 Apr 2026
  50. VIS-01Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries of Denmark. Danish Action Plan for Plant-based Foods. October 2023
  51. VIS-24BMEL (German Federal Ministry of Food and Agriculture). Eiweißpflanzenstrategie
  52. VIS-06Good Food Institute. 2026 State of Global Policy: public investment in protein diversification. April 2026
  53. FTG-14OpenAlex query
  54. SLS-14Krishnan S. et al. (Pukyong National University). Establishment, characterization, and sensory characteristics of an immortalized muscle cell line from the seven-band grouper. 2024
  55. SLS-15Mithra S. et al. (Thiruvalluvar University). Production of small-scale laboratory-grown cell-based fish meat from Asian seabass muscle and fin cell lines. 2025
  56. FTB-38Green Queen. Ayana Bio, Zenfold Buy Meati Foods's Fermentation Assets to Scale Plant Cell Culture Platform in India. 18 Sep 2026
  57. SLF-12AgFunder News. Dohler to dedicate substantial fermentation capacity to make protein-packed postbiotic for Superbrewed Food. 2024-02-14
  58. SLF-14Protein Production Technology. Superbrewed Food sales motivate a search for a larger production site. 2024-04-12
  59. SLW-01NAFOSTED (Ministry of Science and Technology). Thông tin hoạt động tài trợ, hỗ trợ 2023. 2024-11
  60. SLK-20Ho Chi Minh City People's Committee (via LuatVietnam). Quyết định 3204/QĐ-UBND năm 2026 ban hành Điều lệ tổ chức và hoạt động của Quỹ Bảo lãnh tín dụng cho các doanh nghiệp nhỏ và vừa Thành phố Hồ Chí Minh. 2026-05-29
  61. SLK-01State Bank of Vietnam (translation by LuatVietnam). Circular 26/2024/TT-NHNN on financial leasing activities. 2024-06-28
  62. SLK-10Government of Vietnam (translation by LuatVietnam). Decree 45/2024/ND-CP on the SME Development Fund. 2024-04-26
  63. SLK-21Government of Vietnam (translation by LuatVietnam). Decree 57/2018/ND-CP on incentive policies for enterprises investing in agriculture and rural development. 2018-04-17
  64. SLS-13OpenAlex (OurResearch). OpenAlex queries: fish cell lines by Vietnamese farmed species. 2026-10-15
  65. SLS-16Mithra S. et al. (Thiruvalluvar University). Production of cell culture-based micro-tissue from muscle and fin cell lines of Lates calcarifer using biocompatible scaffolds. 2025
  66. SCI-10Soni P, Pradhan PK, Sood N et al. Development, characterization and in vitro applications of a thymus cell line from Pangasianodon hypophthalmus. 2023
  67. CGG-03Coefficient Giving (staff post). Good-tasting alt meat is a scientific problem we can solve. 2026-06-08
  68. CAP-57Coefficient Giving. Request for Proposals: Alternative Protein R&D. 23 Jul 2026
  69. CGG-15Industrial University of Ho Chi Minh City; Ho Chi Minh City University of Technology. Flavor of cooked catfish (Pangasius hypophthalmus) fillets as prediction from raw fresh and frozen-to-thawed. 2011
  70. CGG-16Nong Lam University; Vietnam National University Ho Chi Minh City. Efficiency of intensive tilapia culture in earthen ponds applied biofloc technology, probiotics and off-flavor control methods. 2023
  71. COST-01Ministry of Industry and Trade. Decision 1279/QD-BCT on retail electricity prices. 9 May 2025
  72. COST-19Government of Viet Nam. Decree 293/2025/ND-CP on minimum wages. 10 Nov 2025
  73. COST-21Cushman & Wakefield. Southern Key Economic Zone Industrial MarketBeat Q2 2026. 2026
  74. COST-33CafeF. Cang thang Trung Dong: Phan bon trong nuoc tang, nong san lai giam sau. 7 Apr 2026
  75. COST-43Risner D., McDonald K.A., Jones C.E. A techno-economic model of mycoprotein production: achieving price parity with beef protein. 2023
  76. COST-44Vlaeminck E., Uitterhaegen E., Quataert K., et al. Single-Cell Protein Production from Industrial Off-Gas through Acetate: Techno-Economic Analysis for a Coupled Fermentation Approach. 2023
  77. COST-47Humbird D. Scale-up economics for cultured meat. 2021
  78. FTB-41Green Queen. TurtleTree Earns First US FDA Approval for Cow-Free Lactoferrin Protein. 2025
  79. NGF-11ChiniMandi. India's first 2G ethanol plant at Panipat costs INR 984 crore, government tells Lok Sabha. 2026
  80. NGF-33C&EN. Clariant is latest firm to pull out of cellulosic ethanol. December 2023
  81. MAC-09Bao Ha Tinh. Viet Nam nhap khau 2,61 trieu tan dau tuong nam 2025, kim ngach dat 1,21 ty USD. 8 Mar 2026
  82. PPE-12University of Illinois, farmdoc daily. Trade Conflicts and Long-Term Consequences: Are Soybeans Doomed to Repeat History?. 2025-05-15