AltProtein VietnamProtein thay thế tại Việt NamNghiên cứu xác định phạm vi phía cung · Phiên bản 1.0

Chương 3Phần I: Vì sao là Việt Nam?

3. Vietnam in the region

9 phút đọcNhà đầu tưNhà hoạch định chính sáchStartup và nhà sáng lậpTổ chức quốc tếDoanh nghiệp thực phẩm và thức ăn chăn nuôiCách đọc nhãn bằng chứng

Nội dung trang này bằng tiếng Anh.

Trong trang này
  1. 3.1 How the region scores Vietnam
  2. 3.2 Rules: who approves what
  3. 3.3 Strategies and state money
  4. 3.4 Pilot and contract capacity a Vietnamese company can use
  5. 3.5 Trade: Vietnam sells starch, not fermentation sugar
  6. 3.6 Regional companies with a Vietnam foothold
  7. 3.7 How neighbours built their rules
  8. 3.8 What this means

In brief

  • A 2025 regional study scores Vietnam 100 on labour cost but 0 on regulatory readiness.
  • Cheap inputs alone will not bring plants. Labour and power are a small share of fermentation cost, and Thailand is nearly as cheap, with better rules and more sugar.
  • Singapore approves novel foods; Thailand and Korea have routes but no cultivated approvals yet. China builds at scale and sets the price to beat.
  • Vietnam's regional role today is feedstock supplier. It ships over 2 Mt of cassava starch a year, mostly to China, where it is turned into fermentation sugar.
  • The region points to two moves: keep the starch-to-sugar step at home, and publish a novel-food procedure with a fixed timeline.

3.1 How the region scores Vietnam

The only published regional comparison is the "Where to Build" study (2025) by the Good Food Institute Asia Pacific and Hawkwood Biotech. It scored nine countries from 0 to 100 on seven factors that decide where fermentation plants are built (100 = best in the group)1,2Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc..

FactorVietnam inputVietnam scoreBest in region
LabourUSD 342 a month100Vietnam and Indonesia (100)
UtilitiesUSD 0.08 per kWh97Indonesia (99)
Construction costUSD 1,672 per m²93Indonesia (100)
Business environmentWorld Bank index, about 7030Singapore (100)
Sugar1.35 Mt produced, none exported (2024)26Thailand (100)
Talent779 researchers per million people26Korea (68)
Regulatory readinessNo framework, no approvals0Singapore and Australia (100)

Source:1Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc..

Cheap but unready: how a regional study scores Vietnam

GFI APAC and Hawkwood "Where to Build" (2025), scores 0 to 100, 100 = best of nine countries

Cheap but unready: how a regional study scores VietnamHeatmap: Vietnam scores 100 on labour, 97 on utilities and 93 on construction, but 26 on sugar and talent, 30 on business environment and 0 on regulatory readiness.Score:0 to 1415 to 2829 to 4243 to 5758 to 7172 to 8586 to 100Cost driversEnabling driversConstructioncostUtilitiesLabourSugarcapabilityTalentBusinessenvironmentRegulatoryreadinessVietnamVietnam, Construction cost: 93 out of 100 Group: cost93Vietnam, Utilities: 97 out of 100 Group: cost97Vietnam, Labour: 100 out of 100 Group: cost100Vietnam, Sugar capability: 26 out of 100 Group: enabling26Vietnam, Talent: 26 out of 100 Group: enabling26Vietnam, Business environment: 30 out of 100 Group: enabling30Vietnam, Regulatory readiness: 0 out of 100 Group: enabling0ThailandThailand, Construction cost: 81 out of 100 Group: cost81Thailand, Utilities: 84 out of 100 Group: cost84Thailand, Labour: 99 out of 100 Group: cost99Thailand, Sugar capability: 100 out of 100 Group: enabling100Thailand, Talent: 36 out of 100 Group: enabling36Thailand, Business environment: 74 out of 100 Group: enabling74Thailand, Regulatory readiness: 50 out of 100 Group: enabling50IndonesiaIndonesia, Construction cost: 100 out of 100 Group: cost100Indonesia, Utilities: 99 out of 100 Group: cost99Indonesia, Labour: 100 out of 100 Group: cost100Indonesia, Sugar capability: 14 out of 100 Group: enabling14Indonesia, Talent: 18 out of 100 Group: enabling18Indonesia, Business environment: 29 out of 100 Group: enabling29Indonesia, Regulatory readiness: 0 out of 100 Group: enabling0PhilippinesPhilippines, Construction cost: 94 out of 100 Group: cost94Philippines, Utilities: 75 out of 100 Group: cost75Philippines, Labour: 97 out of 100 Group: cost97Philippines, Sugar capability: 31 out of 100 Group: enabling31Philippines, Talent: 17 out of 100 Group: enabling17Philippines, Business environment: 0 out of 100 Group: enabling0Philippines, Regulatory readiness: 0 out of 100 Group: enabling0MalaysiaMalaysia, Construction cost: 38 out of 100 Group: cost38Malaysia, Utilities: 87 out of 100 Group: cost87Malaysia, Labour: 93 out of 100 Group: cost93Malaysia, Sugar capability: 0 out of 100 Group: enabling0Malaysia, Talent: 29 out of 100 Group: enabling29Malaysia, Business environment: 80 out of 100 Group: enabling80Malaysia, Regulatory readiness: 0 out of 100 Group: enabling0AustraliaAustralia, Construction cost: 0 out of 100 Group: cost0Australia, Utilities: 13 out of 100 Group: cost13Australia, Labour: 0 out of 100 Group: cost0Australia, Sugar capability: 60 out of 100 Group: enabling60Australia, Talent: 50 out of 100 Group: enabling50Australia, Business environment: 79 out of 100 Group: enabling79Australia, Regulatory readiness: 100 out of 100 Group: enabling100South KoreaSouth Korea, Construction cost: 22 out of 100 Group: cost22South Korea, Utilities: 80 out of 100 Group: cost80South Korea, Labour: 29 out of 100 Group: cost29South Korea, Sugar capability: 0 out of 100 Group: enabling0South Korea, Talent: 68 out of 100 Group: enabling68South Korea, Business environment: 91 out of 100 Group: enabling91South Korea, Regulatory readiness: 50 out of 100 Group: enabling50JapanJapan, Construction cost: 5 out of 100 Group: cost5Japan, Utilities: 47 out of 100 Group: cost47Japan, Labour: 27 out of 100 Group: cost27Japan, Sugar capability: 11 out of 100 Group: enabling11Japan, Talent: 49 out of 100 Group: enabling49Japan, Business environment: 65 out of 100 Group: enabling65Japan, Regulatory readiness: 50 out of 100 Group: enabling50SingaporeSingapore, Construction cost: 25 out of 100 Group: cost25Singapore, Utilities: 27 out of 100 Group: cost27Singapore, Labour: 26 out of 100 Group: cost26Singapore, Sugar capability: 0 out of 100 Group: enabling0Singapore, Talent: 55 out of 100 Group: enabling55Singapore, Business environment: 100 out of 100 Group: enabling100Singapore, Regulatory readiness: 100 out of 100 Group: enabling100

Scores are relative scores (min-max normalised) among nine countries, not cost estimates. See ch03 critique.

Nguồn1 Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc.

Xem số liệuẨn số liệu
Cheap but unready: how a regional study scores Vietnam
CountryDriverDriver groupScore (0 to 100)
VietnamSugar capabilityenabling26
VietnamConstruction costcost93
VietnamUtilitiescost97
VietnamLabourcost100
VietnamTalentenabling26
VietnamBusiness environmentenabling30
VietnamRegulatory readinessenabling0
ThailandSugar capabilityenabling100
ThailandConstruction costcost81
ThailandUtilitiescost84
ThailandLabourcost99
ThailandTalentenabling36
ThailandBusiness environmentenabling74
ThailandRegulatory readinessenabling50
IndonesiaSugar capabilityenabling14
IndonesiaConstruction costcost100
IndonesiaUtilitiescost99
IndonesiaLabourcost100
IndonesiaTalentenabling18
IndonesiaBusiness environmentenabling29
IndonesiaRegulatory readinessenabling0
PhilippinesSugar capabilityenabling31
PhilippinesConstruction costcost94
PhilippinesUtilitiescost75
PhilippinesLabourcost97
PhilippinesTalentenabling17
PhilippinesBusiness environmentenabling0
PhilippinesRegulatory readinessenabling0
MalaysiaSugar capabilityenabling0
MalaysiaConstruction costcost38
MalaysiaUtilitiescost87
MalaysiaLabourcost93
MalaysiaTalentenabling29
MalaysiaBusiness environmentenabling80
MalaysiaRegulatory readinessenabling0
AustraliaSugar capabilityenabling60
AustraliaConstruction costcost0
AustraliaUtilitiescost13
AustraliaLabourcost0
AustraliaTalentenabling50
AustraliaBusiness environmentenabling79
AustraliaRegulatory readinessenabling100
South KoreaSugar capabilityenabling0
South KoreaConstruction costcost22
South KoreaUtilitiescost80
South KoreaLabourcost29
South KoreaTalentenabling68
South KoreaBusiness environmentenabling91
South KoreaRegulatory readinessenabling50
JapanSugar capabilityenabling11
JapanConstruction costcost5
JapanUtilitiescost47
JapanLabourcost27
JapanTalentenabling49
JapanBusiness environmentenabling65
JapanRegulatory readinessenabling50
SingaporeSugar capabilityenabling0
SingaporeConstruction costcost25
SingaporeUtilitiescost27
SingaporeLabourcost26
SingaporeTalentenabling55
SingaporeBusiness environmentenabling100
SingaporeRegulatory readinessenabling100

Three points matter more than the ranks.

  1. Vietnam is not unique on cost. Indonesia scores as well or better on labour, utilities and construction. Thailand is nearly as cheap and scores far higher on sugar, business and rules1Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc..
  2. Cheap inputs act on a small share of cost. In the study's model plants, labour and power together are only about 12% to 21% of cost. Feedstock is the largest line, at 37% to 56%1Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc..
  3. The sugar score understates Vietnam. It ignores cassava starch, Vietnam's main fermentable carbohydrate (Asset map). But most of that starch is already sold abroad (section 3.5).

The study's three recommendations for Vietnam are all about rules1Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc.:

  • fund the 2023 biotechnology resolution through programmes with named agency mandates;
  • make clear which sites qualify for incentives, and when;
  • "publish regulatory procedures and statutory timelines for novel food approvals".

It also finds that a capital grant, cheaper feedstock or a loan guarantee does more for a project than a tax holiday1Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc.. The study is a useful map of relative position, not a site-selection model: it gives no cost per kilogram and uses an outdated business index1Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..

3.2 Rules: who approves what

Singapore approves novel foods. Most neighbours have a route but few or no approvals.

CountryNovel-food routeCultivated meat routeApprovals (September 2026)Sources
SingaporeApproval before sale since 2019, now in lawYes18 novel foods3,4Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc.
ThailandMinisterial notification (2016), with recognised assessorsApplications accepted since 2024No cultivated approval5,6Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.
South KoreaTemporary standards, extended to cell culture in 2024; review up to 270 working daysYesNone found7,8,9Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.
JapanCase by case; draft guidance May 2026DraftNone found10Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.
ChinaNew food raw material approvalsExpected from late 2026Fungal and yeast protein reported11,12Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu.
Australia and New ZealandNovel and cell-cultured food standardsYesCultivated quail (2025)13,14Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.
Malaysia, Indonesia, PhilippinesGeneral provision or noneNoNone found1,7,14Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.
VietnamNo novel-food category (Rules)NoNone1Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.

Singapore's list includes six cultivated meats, six fungal or bacterial proteins and three precision-fermented ingredients3,15Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc.. In the United States, cultivated salmon was cleared in 202516Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc..

Novel-protein approvals in the region and the US

Approvals by date, country and category

Novel-protein approvals in the region and the USDot timeline: Singapore holds most approvals from 2019 to 2026; the United States, Australia and New Zealand follow; no approvals in Vietnam, Thailand, Korea or Malaysia.CultivatedBiomassPrecision fermentation (PF)Other (microalgae, chemical synthesis, PF / biomass, religious ruling)Application or ruling, not an approval201920202021202220232024202520262027SingaporeSingapore, 2019-05-21: Chlamydomonas reinhardtii THN6 (green) algae biomass Category: other (microalgae) Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Triton Algae Innovations Product: Chlamydomonas reinhardtii THN6 (green) algae biomass Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2020-11-26: Cultured chicken cells (UMNSAH/DF1) Category: cultivated Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Eat Just, Inc. Product: Cultured chicken cells (UMNSAH/DF1) Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2021-08-06: Mycelial biomass, Fusarium strain flavolapis (Fy) Category: biomass Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Nature's Fynd Product: Mycelial biomass, Fusarium strain flavolapis (Fy) Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2022-09-29: Protein powder from Xanthobacter sp. SOF1 (Solein) Category: biomass Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Solar Foods Oy Product: Protein powder from Xanthobacter sp. SOF1 (Solein) Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2022-10-19: Chlamydomonas reinhardtii TAI114 (red) algae biomass Category: other (microalgae) Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Triton Algae Innovations Product: Chlamydomonas reinhardtii TAI114 (red) algae biomass Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2023-01-11: Cultured chicken cells, serum-free media Category: cultivated Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Eat Just, Inc. Product: Cultured chicken cells, serum-free media Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2023-02-20: Animal-free beta-lactoglobulin (Komagataella phaffii) Category: PF Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Remilk Product: Animal-free beta-lactoglobulin (Komagataella phaffii) Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2024-03-14: Fungal biomass, Rhizomucor pusillus (Fermotein) Category: biomass Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: The Protein Brewery B.V. Product: Fungal biomass, Rhizomucor pusillus (Fermotein) Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2024-03-22: Cultured Japanese quail fibroblasts Category: cultivated Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Vow Group Pty Ltd Product: Cultured Japanese quail fibroblasts Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2024-10-15: Mycoprotein, Neurospora crassa Bstr 26 (Rhiza) Category: biomass Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: The Better Meat Co. Product: Mycoprotein, Neurospora crassa Bstr 26 (Rhiza) Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2025-03-13: Urolithin A Category: other (chemical synthesis) Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Amazentis SA Product: Urolithin A Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2025-06-18: 3'-sialyllactose sodium salt (GM E. coli) Category: PF Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Chr. Hansen Singapore Pte Ltd Product: 3'-sialyllactose sodium salt (GM E. coli) Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2025-06-18: 6'-sialyllactose sodium salt (GM E. coli) Category: PF Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Chr. Hansen Singapore Pte Ltd Product: 6'-sialyllactose sodium salt (GM E. coli) Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2025-09-24: Mycelium biomass, Pleurotus pulmonarius Category: biomass Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Infinite Roots Product: Mycelium biomass, Pleurotus pulmonarius Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2025-10-17: Cultivated chicken biomass (embryonic stem cells) Category: cultivated Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Vital Meat (Parima group) Product: Cultivated chicken biomass (embryonic stem cells) Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2026-04-10: Cultured duck (embryonic stem cells) Category: cultivated Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Supreme SAS (Parima group, ex-Gourmey) Product: Cultured duck (embryonic stem cells) Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2026-04-27: Mycoprotein, Neurospora crassa OR-1 (Noushroom) Category: biomass Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Ultimeat International Pte Ltd Product: Mycoprotein, Neurospora crassa OR-1 (Noushroom) Regulator: Singapore Food AgencySingapore, 2026-07-22: Cultivated thin-cut steak (bovine cells; hybrid with plant protein) Category: cultivated Form: Listed as approved novel food (pre-market approval) Company: Aleph Farms Product: Cultivated thin-cut steak (bovine cells; hybrid with plant protein) Regulator: Singapore Food AgencyUnited StatesUnited States, 2022-11-16: Cultured chicken cells Category: cultivated Form: Pre-market consultation completed, 'no questions' letter Company: UPSIDE Foods Product: Cultured chicken cells Regulator: US FDAUnited States, 2023-03-20: Cultured chicken cells Category: cultivated Form: Pre-market consultation completed, 'no questions' letter Company: GOOD Meat, Inc. Product: Cultured chicken cells Regulator: US FDAUnited States, 2025-03-07: Cultured pork fat cells Category: cultivated Form: Pre-market consultation completed, 'no questions' letter Company: Mission Barns Product: Cultured pork fat cells Regulator: US FDAUnited States, 2025-05-28: Cultured coho salmon cells (Oncorhynchus kisutch) Category: cultivated Form: Pre-market consultation completed, 'no questions' letter Company: Wildtype Inc. Product: Cultured coho salmon cells (Oncorhynchus kisutch) Regulator: US FDAUnited States, 2025-07-24: Cultured chicken cells Category: cultivated Form: Pre-market consultation completed, 'no questions' letter Company: Believer Meats Product: Cultured chicken cells Regulator: US FDAAustralia/New ZealandAustralia/New Zealand, 2025-04-07: Cultured quail Category: cultivated Form: Food Standards Code amendment (approval by FSANZ; Code change in force mid-2025) Company: Vow Group Pty Ltd Product: Cultured quail Regulator: FSANZIsraelIsrael, 2023-12 / 2024-01: Cultivated beef Category: cultivated Form: Novel food approval Company: Aleph Farms Product: Cultivated beef Regulator: Ministry of Health, National Food ServiceThailandThailand, 2024-12-05 (filed): Cultivated beef Category: cultivated Form: APPLICATION ONLY, not approved as of Sep 2026 Company: Aleph Farms Product: Cultivated beef Regulator: Thai FDA; BIOTEC as Safety Assessment UnitChinaChina, 2025 (exact date not verified): Fusarium venenatum mycoprotein Category: biomass Form: New food raw material approval Company: Fushine Biotech Product: Fusarium venenatum mycoprotein Regulator: National Health CommissionChina, not verified: Yeast protein Category: biomass Form: New food raw material approval (per GFI report) Company: Angel Yeast Product: Yeast protein Regulator: National Health CommissionAngel Yeast: date not verifiedIndiaIndia, not verified: Whey protein (PF); Fy fungal protein; algae ingredient; mycoprotein Category: PF / biomass Form: Non-specified food approval Company: Perfect Day; Nature's Fynd; Reliance; others Product: Whey protein (PF); Fy fungal protein; algae ingredient; mycoprotein Regulator: FSSAIPerfect Day; Nature's Fynd; Reliance; others: date not verifiedMalaysiaMalaysia, 2025-12: Cultivated meat (category) Category: other (religious ruling) Form: Ruling that cultivated meat can be halal under conditions; NOT a food safety approval Company: n/a (national fatwa) Product: Cultivated meat (category) Regulator: National fatwa authority / JAKIMSouth KoreaSouth Korea, none as of 2026-09: Cultivated meat Category: cultivated Form: No approval found Company: (applications reported) Product: Cultivated meat Regulator: MFDSNo approval foundJapanJapan, none as of 2026-09: Cultivated meat Category: cultivated Form: No approval; draft safety checkpoints 28 May 2026 Company: n/a Product: Cultivated meat Regulator: Consumer Affairs AgencyNo approval; draft safety checkpoints 28 May 2026VietnamVietnam, none: n/a Category: n/a Form: No novel food route Company: n/a Product: n/a Regulator: MOH / VFANo novel food route

Nguồn3,16,13,14 Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.

Xem số liệuẨn số liệu
Novel-protein approvals in the region and the US
DateCountryCompanyProductCategoryRegulatorForm of approval
2019-05-21SingaporeTriton Algae InnovationsChlamydomonas reinhardtii THN6 (green) algae biomassother (microalgae)Singapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2020-11-26SingaporeEat Just, Inc.Cultured chicken cells (UMNSAH/DF1)cultivatedSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2021-08-06SingaporeNature's FyndMycelial biomass, Fusarium strain flavolapis (Fy)biomassSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2022-09-29SingaporeSolar Foods OyProtein powder from Xanthobacter sp. SOF1 (Solein)biomassSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2022-10-19SingaporeTriton Algae InnovationsChlamydomonas reinhardtii TAI114 (red) algae biomassother (microalgae)Singapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2023-01-11SingaporeEat Just, Inc.Cultured chicken cells, serum-free mediacultivatedSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2023-02-20SingaporeRemilkAnimal-free beta-lactoglobulin (Komagataella phaffii)PFSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2024-03-14SingaporeThe Protein Brewery B.V.Fungal biomass, Rhizomucor pusillus (Fermotein)biomassSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2024-03-22SingaporeVow Group Pty LtdCultured Japanese quail fibroblastscultivatedSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2024-10-15SingaporeThe Better Meat Co.Mycoprotein, Neurospora crassa Bstr 26 (Rhiza)biomassSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2025-03-13SingaporeAmazentis SAUrolithin Aother (chemical synthesis)Singapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2025-06-18SingaporeChr. Hansen Singapore Pte Ltd3'-sialyllactose sodium salt (GM E. coli)PFSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2025-06-18SingaporeChr. Hansen Singapore Pte Ltd6'-sialyllactose sodium salt (GM E. coli)PFSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2025-09-24SingaporeInfinite RootsMycelium biomass, Pleurotus pulmonariusbiomassSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2025-10-17SingaporeVital Meat (Parima group)Cultivated chicken biomass (embryonic stem cells)cultivatedSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2026-04-10SingaporeSupreme SAS (Parima group, ex-Gourmey)Cultured duck (embryonic stem cells)cultivatedSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2026-04-27SingaporeUltimeat International Pte LtdMycoprotein, Neurospora crassa OR-1 (Noushroom)biomassSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2026-07-22SingaporeAleph FarmsCultivated thin-cut steak (bovine cells; hybrid with plant protein)cultivatedSingapore Food AgencyListed as approved novel food (pre-market approval)
2022-11-16United StatesUPSIDE FoodsCultured chicken cellscultivatedUS FDAPre-market consultation completed, 'no questions' letter
2023-03-20United StatesGOOD Meat, Inc.Cultured chicken cellscultivatedUS FDAPre-market consultation completed, 'no questions' letter
2025-03-07United StatesMission BarnsCultured pork fat cellscultivatedUS FDAPre-market consultation completed, 'no questions' letter
2025-05-28United StatesWildtype Inc.Cultured coho salmon cells (Oncorhynchus kisutch)cultivatedUS FDAPre-market consultation completed, 'no questions' letter
2025-07-24United StatesBeliever MeatsCultured chicken cellscultivatedUS FDAPre-market consultation completed, 'no questions' letter
2025-04-07Australia/New ZealandVow Group Pty LtdCultured quailcultivatedFSANZFood Standards Code amendment (approval by FSANZ; Code change in force mid-2025)
2023-12 / 2024-01IsraelAleph FarmsCultivated beefcultivatedMinistry of Health, National Food ServiceNovel food approval
2024-12-05 (filed)ThailandAleph FarmsCultivated beefcultivatedThai FDA; BIOTEC as Safety Assessment UnitAPPLICATION ONLY, not approved as of Sep 2026
2025 (exact date not verified)ChinaFushine BiotechFusarium venenatum mycoproteinbiomassNational Health CommissionNew food raw material approval
not verifiedChinaAngel YeastYeast proteinbiomassNational Health CommissionNew food raw material approval (per GFI report)
not verifiedIndiaPerfect Day; Nature's Fynd; Reliance; othersWhey protein (PF); Fy fungal protein; algae ingredient; mycoproteinPF / biomassFSSAINon-specified food approval
2025-12Malaysian/a (national fatwa)Cultivated meat (category)other (religious ruling)National fatwa authority / JAKIMRuling that cultivated meat can be halal under conditions; NOT a food safety approval
none as of 2026-09South Korea(applications reported)Cultivated meatcultivatedMFDSNo approval found
none as of 2026-09Japann/aCultivated meatcultivatedConsumer Affairs AgencyNo approval; draft safety checkpoints 28 May 2026
noneVietnamn/an/an/aMOH / VFANo novel food route

A route is not an approval. Korea and Thailand opened applications in 2024, but neither had approved a cultivated product by September 202614,8,6,9Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. Staff and published review times matter as much as the legal text.

Halal. In 2025 Malaysia ruled that cultivated meat can be halal14,17,18Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. This matters for any Vietnamese product aimed at Malaysian, Indonesian or Middle Eastern buyers.

3.3 Strategies and state money

Neighbours have strategies with public money behind them. We found no alternative-protein budget line in Vietnam.

CountryStrategyMoney foundSources
Singapore2025 food strategy; alternative protein left out of 2035 targetsS$144 M research programme (2019); S$42 M for future-food projects (2025)19,20,21Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.
ThailandBiotechnology framework 2026 to 2035 names alternative protein; plans public pilot and contract-manufacturing plantsProposed 500 M baht a year for synthetic biology22Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.
South KoreaFood tech promotion law; cultivated-meat research centre (2027)About USD 10 M for the centre7,8Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.
ChinaPlans for new feed protein and "new types of food"About USD 1 bn of state investment in biotech plants (2025)21,11,12,23,24Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.
Vietnam2023 biotechnology resolution; high-tech incentives (Rules)No alternative-protein line found1Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.

Two moves matter directly for Vietnam.

  • Thailand is responding to the same ranking. It plans public pilot and contract-manufacturing plants22Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. A Vietnamese project would then compete with a neighbour that has cheaper sugar, a working approval route and public pilot plants.
  • Singapore has stepped back from production. It now acts as regulator, research centre and financier19,20Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. That leaves room for cheaper neighbours to make Singapore-approved products, if their plants meet Singapore's import rules (Unknowns).

3.4 Pilot and contract capacity a Vietnamese company can use

A Vietnamese company that needs a pilot plant today has to go abroad. Several plants offer tolling: renting time on someone else's fermenter.

FacilityCountryWhatFood statusSources
ScaleUp BioSingaporeUp to 10,000 L of fermentation plus processingFood licence (2024)25,26,27,28Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc.
EECi Biorefinery Pilot PlantThailand12 fermenters, up to 15,000 L; contract manufacturingNot stated29Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.
Chinese contract manufacturersChinaLargest and cheapest; may keep process know-howVaries11Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.

Vietnam has no open food-grade pilot plant (Industrial base). So a Vietnamese startup scales up in Singapore (licensed but dear), Thailand (larger tanks, food status to confirm) or China (cheapest, but exposes more know-how).

China sets the price. Angel Yeast makes about 11,000 t a year of yeast protein, and a 20,000 t a year fungal protein plant began runs in June 2026. One foreign client said scale-up in China took half the time and half the cost11Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. Any Vietnamese microbial protein will be priced against these plants.

3.5 Trade: Vietnam sells starch, not fermentation sugar

Imports of food protein ingredients are small. Vietnam reported about USD 56 million of imports of soy isolate, protein concentrates and textured protein in 2023, mostly from the United States and China30,31Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. Chinese export data show larger tonnages at prices that suggest much is feed-grade32,33,34,35Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..

Carbohydrate exports are large. Vietnam exported 2.15 Mt of cassava starch worth USD 1.06 billion in 2023, 94% of it to China36Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc.. In 2024 China bought 39% of its cassava starch imports from Vietnam, but only USD 0.16 million of glucose syrup37,38,39,40Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc..

Vietnam sells starch, not fermentation sugar

USD million; Vietnam-reported exports (2023) and China-reported imports from Vietnam (2024)

Vietnam sells starch, not fermentation sugarBars: USD 1,063 million of cassava starch exported in 2023; China bought USD 757 million of starch, 114 million of modified starch and 104 million of dried cassava from Vietnam in 2024, but only USD 0.16 million of glucose syrup.Vietnam exports, worldChina imports from Vietnam03006009001,200USD millionCassava starchVietnam-reported, 2023Cassava starch, Vietnam exports, world, 2023: USD 1,063 million Volume, kt: 2,150 HS code: 1,108.14 Reporter: Vietnam Year: 2,023USD 1,063 millionCassava starchChina-reported, 2024Cassava starch, China imports from Vietnam, 2024: USD 757 million Volume, kt: 1,560 HS code: 1,108.14 Reporter: China Year: 2,024USD 757 millionModified starchChina-reported, 2024Modified starch, China imports from Vietnam, 2024: USD 114 million Volume, kt: 179 HS code: 3,505.10 Reporter: China Year: 2,024USD 114 millionDried cassavaChina-reported, 2024Dried cassava, China imports from Vietnam, 2024: USD 104 million Volume, kt: 412 HS code: 0,714.10 Reporter: China Year: 2,024USD 104 millionGlucose syrupChina-reported, 2024Glucose syrup, China imports from Vietnam, 2024: USD 0.16 million Volume, kt: 0.175 HS code: 1,702.30 Reporter: China Year: 2,024USD 0.16 million

Nguồn37,38,36,39,40 Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc.

Xem số liệuẨn số liệu
Vietnam sells starch, not fermentation sugar
ProductFlowYearValue (USD million)Volume (kt)HS codeReporter
Cassava starchVietnam exports, world20231,0632,1501108.14Vietnam
Cassava starchChina imports from Vietnam20247571,5601108.14China
Modified starchChina imports from Vietnam20241141793505.10China
Dried cassavaChina imports from Vietnam20241044120714.10China
Glucose syrupChina imports from Vietnam20240.160.1751702.30China

Reading. For exported starch, the step to glucose, the feedstock of every fermentation plant, happens in China. Vietnam makes glucose too, but for the maker's own use or the home market41Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. Moving part of that step to Vietnam is the most direct way to plug into the regional build-out (Plays, play T4).

3.6 Regional companies with a Vietnam foothold

CompanyAlternative-protein activityVietnam linkSources
AjinomotoPartner of Solar Foods; launched its gas-fermented protein in Japan and SingaporeLarge fermentation plants in Vietnam (Industrial base)42,43,44Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.
Thai UnionEarly investor in Aleph Farms (cultivated beef)Owns a Vietnamese seafood canner6,45Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.
CJ CheilJedang, DaesangKorean firms developing cultivated meatDaesang runs fermentation and starch plants in Vietnam; CJ runs CJ Foods Vietnam7,9,46,47,48Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.

These firms already own fermentation, food or seafood plants in Vietnam. They are the likeliest hosts for a first tolling or pilot arrangement (Plays, play T5).

3.7 How neighbours built their rules

SingaporeThailandSouth Korea
TriggerOver 90% import dependence; new food agencyGreen economy agenda; foreign applicantsIndustrial policy; conglomerate research
InstrumentNew approval before sale, later written into lawMinisterial notification plus recognised assessorsAmended an existing rule in about nine months
First cultivated approvalAbout 2 years (2020)None by September 2026None by September 2026
Worth copyingPublic list with specifications; help before applyingExisting science bodies as assessorsPublished fee and review time

Sources:3,7,6,9,49,5Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..

Lessons that transfer (our assessment).Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.

  1. A new law is not needed. Korea added a step to an existing rule in about nine months. Vietnam's equivalent is a clause in the Food Safety Law now being drafted, with a procedure in its decree (Rules, Policy options).
  2. Borrow assessors. Thailand named existing bodies as assessors. Vietnam could use the National Institute for Food Control.
  3. Rely on others' work. Vietnam already accepts five trusted countries' approvals for genetically modified (GM) food (Rules). The same logic can apply to novel foods.
  4. Publish the timeline. A published fee and review period give applicants something to plan around.

3.8 What this means

  • Investors: Vietnam is a cost story without a food approval route. Until one exists, export under another country's approval is the clearer route. Price any microbial protein against Chinese plants.
  • Policy makers: publish a novel-food procedure with a fixed timeline, and pair it with capital grants rather than tax holidays. Thailand is already acting.
  • Startups: plan scale-up in Singapore, Thailand or China, and use a Singapore approval as the regional credential. Budget 9 to 12 months or more after a complete application50Bằng chứng: bằng chứng từ một nước tương đồng, có nêu giả định chuyển đổi (VN-adjacent); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu..
  • Manufacturers: the bigger lever is not protein imports (about USD 56 million) but the starch Vietnam already ships to China.
  • Researchers: Chinese cassava-to-protein work and Thai pilot plants are the fastest partnerships for catching up.
  • International bodies: help draft the procedure, and consider a Thailand-Vietnam pilot-plant access arrangement.

Related: Rules, Export demand, International.

Nguồn được trích dẫn trong trang

Các số trong bài dẫn đến danh sách này. Mọi nguồn cũng có trong danh sách nguồn đầy đủ. Danh sách nguồn đầy đủ

  1. RGN-01Morton, J., Powell, D. (GFI APAC) and Day, T. (Hawkwood Biotech). Where to Build: site selection and competitiveness in APAC fermentation manufacturing. October 2025
  2. RGN-02Huling, R. Three APAC countries with the right ingredients to dominate biomanufacturing. Oct 2025
  3. RGN-04Singapore Food Agency. SFA list of approved novel foods. 14 Aug 2026
  4. REG-63Singapore Food Agency. Novel Food. 27 Aug 2026
  5. REG2-26Thai FDA. Thai FDA Food Division, Food law: Novel food
  6. RGN-32Aleph Farms. Aleph Farms Submits First-Ever Application for Cultivated Meat in Thailand. 5 Dec 2024
  7. RGN-19GFI APAC. State of Play: APAC. June 2025
  8. RGN-21GFI APAC. Korea overtakes Singapore as APAC's cultivated meat startup epicentre. 21 Apr 2026
  9. RGN-34Cultivated X. South Korea's Ministry of Food and Drug Safety Accepting Submissions for Cultivated Meat Approval. 23 Feb 2024
  10. RGN-33Cultivated X. Japan Releases Draft Safety Checkpoints for Cultivated Meat and Seafood Products. 4 Jun 2026
  11. RGN-24van der Kley, D. China Biomanufacturing Study Report. 31 Jul 2026
  12. RGN-25GFI APAC. An Exclusive Look Inside China's 'New Proteins' Sector. 2025
  13. RGN-18Wikipedia. Cultured meat
  14. RGN-20GFI APAC. GFI APAC's 2025 Report Card + 6 Things to Watch in 2026. Jan 2026
  15. RGN-29Green Queen. Aleph Farms Secures Singapore Approval for Cultivated Beef, Targets 2027 Restaurant Launch. 4 Aug 2026
  16. RGN-03US FDA. Human Food Made with Cultured Animal Cells Inventory
  17. RGN-28GFI APAC. Why Singapore's World-First Cultivated Beef and Duck Approvals Matter. 28 Aug 2026
  18. RGN-30FoodNavigator. Cultivated beef steak to hit Singapore food scene with historic approval. 4 Aug 2026
  19. RGN-08Ministry of Sustainability and the Environment (Singapore). Oral Reply to Parliamentary Question on Revised Local Production Targets. 13 Jan 2026
  20. RGN-09Green Queen. Singapore Food Security Plan Drops '30 By 30' Policy & Lab-Grown Meat. 6 Nov 2025
  21. RGN-22GFI APAC. How governments are supporting sustainable protein research in APAC. undated
  22. RGN-35NXPO (Office of National Higher Education Science Research and Innovation Policy Council), Thailand. Biotechnology Industry Development Framework B.E. 2569-2578 (Nov 2025; uploaded Apr 2026)
  23. RGN-43GFI. Alternative proteins: State of global policy. 2025
  24. RGN-56Sun, H., Jiang, Z., Chen, Z. et al. Effects of fermented unconventional protein feed on pig production in China. 2024
  25. RGN-10ScaleUp Bio. ScaleUp Bio, home page
  26. RGN-11ScaleUp Bio via PR Newswire. ScaleUp Bio Announces Fusionopolis Ventures Joining ADM as Shareholder. 26 Mar 2026
  27. RGN-12APFoodOnline. ScaleUp Bio secures strategic investment from Fusionopolis Ventures. 26 Mar 2026
  28. RGN-13Green Queen. ScaleUp Bio's Precision Fermentation Plant Earns Singapore Production Licence. 21 May 2024
  29. RGN-36EECi. Biorefinery Pilot Plant
  30. RGN-45Vietnam imports HS 3504. World Bank WITS (UN Comtrade). 2023
  31. RGN-46Vietnam imports HS 2106. World Bank WITS. 2023
  32. RGN-47China exports HS 350400 by partner. World Bank WITS. 2024
  33. RGN-48China exports HS 350400 by partner. World Bank WITS. 2023
  34. RGN-49China exports HS 210610 by partner. World Bank WITS. 2024
  35. RGN-50China exports HS 210610 by partner. World Bank WITS. 2023
  36. RGN-53Vietnam exports HS 110814 by partner. World Bank WITS. 2023
  37. RGN-51China imports HS 110814 (cassava starch) by partner. World Bank WITS. 2024
  38. RGN-52China imports HS 071410 (cassava) by partner. World Bank WITS. 2024
  39. RGN-54China imports HS 350510 (dextrins, modified starch) by partner. World Bank WITS. 2024
  40. RGN-55China imports HS 170230 (glucose) by partner. World Bank WITS. 2024
  41. VCO-03Vedan International. Milestones. undated
  42. RGN-40Solar Foods. Solar Foods, news page
  43. RGN-60Ajinomoto Vietnam. Ajinomoto Vietnam, home page
  44. IND-10Ajinomoto Vietnam. Ajinomoto Viet Nam ung dung cong nghe san xuat bot ngot hoan toan moi
  45. RGN-58Wikipedia. Thai Union Group
  46. IND-11Daesang Vietnam. About Daesang Vietnam (history, plants)
  47. VCO-08Royal De Heus. De Heus successfully completes acquisition of CJ Feed & Care, marking a significant expansion in Asia. 3 Mar 2026
  48. FORM-24CJ Foods Vietnam homepage. CJ Foods Việt Nam
  49. RGN-44GFI APAC. Spotlight: Singapore Food Agency's regulatory leadership
  50. RGN-17GFI India. Novel food regulations around the world. 4 Aug 2026