AltProtein VietnamProtein thay thế tại Việt NamNghiên cứu xác định phạm vi phía cung · Phiên bản 1.0

Chương 26Phần V: Nên làm gì?

26. Seven plays and four public goods

Nội dung trang này bằng tiếng Anh.

Trong trang này
  1. 26.1 How the plays are scored
  2. 26.2 The scores: T1, T4 and T5 lead
  3. 26.3 The plays
  4. 26.4 Four public goods
  5. 26.5 Sequencing: a portfolio view
  6. 26.6 What we do not recommend, and why
  7. 26.7 What this means
  8. 26.8 Three candidates from the solutions screen

In brief

  • A "play" is a specific business or programme someone could start in Vietnam, with a named product, buyer and partner. We describe seven, all about protein for people.
  • Each play states what has to be true and the tests that would kill it, so readers can check it. We publish the scores and weights, so each reader can re-rank them.
  • Three plays lead: domestic textured plant protein (T1), a hub that turns cassava starch into fermentation sugar (T4), and shared pilot and tolling fermentation (T5), where firms rent time on someone else's fermenter.
  • The textured-protein line is cheap to equip but pays only if food-grade soy flour costs below about USD 700 to 940 per t. So it suits an established firm with buyers and bank credit better than a startup.
  • Four public goods, mainly rules, a laboratory and data, would lower the cost of every play.
  • We screened 170 published solutions; none displaces the leading plays. Three candidates are listed but not yet ranked (section 26.8).

26.1 How the plays are scored

We score each play from 1 to 5 on seven criteria. The weighted score is each score times its weight, added up and divided by 100.

CriterionWhat a 5 meansWhat a 1 means
Market pullSeveral named buyers already buy the imported or existing equivalentNo identifiable buyer
Vietnam advantageA clear, hard-to-copy Vietnamese edgeAny neighbour does it as well
Technical readinessCommercial elsewhere, skills in VietnamLaboratory stage
Route to marketOrdinary food rules applyNo legal route
Capital efficiencyFirst revenue for under a few million USD, or by renting tanksTens to hundreds of millions before revenue
DefensibilityFunction, logistics or patents that imports cannot matchA commodity with cheaper imports
Public valueLarge contribution to protein security or national capabilityLittle wider benefit

Weights by audience, in percent. Each row adds up to 100. DFIs are development finance institutions.

PresetMarketAdvantageReadinessRouteCapitalDefensibilityPublic value
Balanced15151515151015
Investors2510151020155
Policy makers1020105101035
Startups201020202055
Manufacturers301025151055
Research bodies102510105535
International bodies and DFIs1020151010530

26.2 The scores: T1, T4 and T5 lead

PlayMarketAdvantageReadinessRouteCapitalDefensibilityPublic valueBalanced score
T1 Domestic textured plant protein43554233.80
T4 Cassava starch to fermentation sugar hub25553343.90
T5 Shared pilot and tolling fermentation24442353.45
T7 High-value, low-dose precision fermentation22213322.10
T8 Cultivated seafood research12112221.55
T9 Koji and fungal foods on side streams23344323.00
T10 Mung bean and rice protein for plant drinks32353233.05

Source: AltProtein Vietnam scoring (Technology fit and the evidence cited in each play)Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..

Seven plays, scored with weights you can change

Weighted score (1 to 5) by audience preset

Seven plays, scored with weights you can changeBar chart of weighted scores for seven plays: under balanced weights the cassava-starch-to-sugar hub (3.90) and domestic textured plant protein (3.80) lead, followed by shared pilot and tolling fermentation (3.45), mung bean and rice protein for plant drinks (3.05) and koji and fungal foods (3.00).012345Weighted score, balanced weights (1 to 5)T4 Cassava starch to fermentation sugarhubT4 Cassava starch to fermentation sugar hub: 3.90 (balanced weights, 1 to 5) Must be true: Cassava prices stabilise after the 2025 to 2026 spike and the E10 mandate; at least one fermenter commits to co-locate; wastewater and biogas infrastructure can serve fermentation Kill tests: No fermenter commits within two years; cassava price volatility makes long-term sugar contracts impossible Horizon: 1 to 3 years3.90T1 Domestic textured plant proteinT1 Domestic textured plant protein: 3.80 (balanced weights, 1 to 5) Must be true: Ex-factory cost at or below landed Chinese textured protein (USD 1.24/kg FOB in 2025; USD 1.29 to 1.38/kg landed; 0% duty under ACFTA and RCEP) (TIC-12; BUY-02; FTR-32); a food-grade, low-temperature defatted soy flour supply below the breakeven price (about USD 700 to 940 per t delivered for a 1 t/h line at 70% utilisation; our calculation, TIC-12; TIC-13); buyers value freshness, customisation and local supply Kill tests: Delivered food-grade flour costs more than about USD 700 to 940 per t (1 t/h at 70%) or USD 590 to 900 per t (0.5 t/h at 70%); fewer than three buyers sign conditional orders totalling at least 2,000 t a year; Chinese landed price (USD 1.29 to 1.38/kg in 2025) stays below Vietnamese full cost at 2,800 t a year (0.5 t/h at 70%) or 5,600 t a year (1 t/h at 70%), on 8,000 operating hours a year; India-origin textured soy (USD 0.98/kg FOB in 2025) becomes the reference price; Version 0.10: no bank agrees to finance the supplier's receivables against the anchor buyer (supply-chain finance or factoring); without an anchor the working capital of USD 0.6 to 3.5 million has no named source Horizon: 0 to 2 years3.80T5 Shared pilot and tolling fermentationT5 Shared pilot and tolling fermentation: 3.45 (balanced weights, 1 to 5) Must be true: An anchor host (industrial producer, Saigon Hi-Tech Park, FIRI or a university) and an operator; enough users to fill the line; public or DFI co-funding Kill tests: No host agrees to tolling terms; utilisation below about a third in the first two years Horizon: 2 to 4 years3.45T10 Mung bean and rice protein for plantdrinksT10 Mung bean and rice protein for plant drinks: 3.05 (balanced weights, 1 to 5) Must be true: Functional and sensory parity in drinks; cost near imported pea protein; a buyer specification; a reliable mung bean supply (65% of imports come from Myanmar); Version 0.10: raw material must fit the price. At 2023 to 2025 import prices, mung beans alone cost USD 3.0 to 4.9 per kg of isolate (60 to 80% protein recovery assumed), above Chinese pea protein at USD 2 to 3 per kg, so the line needs a paid starch co-product or a higher-priced job such as egg-white replacement (TPP-05); rice protein from broken rice costs USD 5.1 to 6.6 per kg of product in raw material alone, so the rice arm works only as a co-product of a rice syrup or starch line, and we found no such line in Vietnam (our calculation) Kill tests: Buyer rejects on taste or stability; cost above imported pea protein by more than a local-sourcing premium buyers will pay; Version 0.10: no buyer for the mung bean starch co-product at a price that brings raw-material cost inside the TPP-05 band; for the rice arm, no rice syrup or starch host within two years Horizon: 2 to 4 years3.05T9 Koji and fungal foods on food-grade sidestreamsT9 Koji and fungal foods on food-grade side streams: 3.00 (balanced weights, 1 to 5) Must be true: A characterised strain with no cyclopiazonic acid or 3-nitropropionic acid risk; a food-grade substrate supply; consumer acceptance in chay and mainstream dishes Kill tests: Strain safety data cannot be obtained; sensory trials fail with target buyers Horizon: 1 to 3 years3.00T7 High-value, low-doseprecision-fermentation ingredientsT7 High-value, low-dose precision-fermentation ingredients: 2.10 (balanced weights, 1 to 5) Must be true: A product where titers of 1 to 10 g/L are economic; freedom to operate (OPENPichia or licensed strains); a foreign approval or an ingredient use outside novel-food rules; a clear GMO pathway under Decree 43/2026 Kill tests: No customer letter of intent after a sample programme; contract-manufacturing cost above the target price at pilot scale Horizon: 2 to 5 years2.10T8 Cultivated seafood researchT8 Cultivated seafood research: 1.55 (balanced weights, 1 to 5) Must be true: A food-suitable cell line; research funding over 5 years or more; a partner with scale-up know-how; Version 0.10: the published cost model assumes an engineered cell line with efficient metabolism; that line must exist for a Vietnamese species Kill tests: No serum-free, suspension-capable line after 3 years of work; Version 0.10: no hydrolysate-based medium supports fish-cell growth over several passages within three years Horizon: 5 to 10 years or more1.55Top three under each presetPresetFirstSecondThirdBalancedT4 (3.90)T1 (3.80)T5 (3.45)InvestorsT1 (3.80)T4 (3.50)T5 and T9 (3.00)Policy makersT4 (3.95)T5 (3.85)T1 (3.40)StartupsT1 (4.15)T4 (3.85)T10 (3.25)Food manufacturersT1 (4.15)T4 (3.75)T5 (3.20)Research bodiesT4 (4.15)T5 (4.00)T1 (3.50)International bodies and DFIsT4 (4.10)T5 (3.85)T1 (3.65)

Trọng số cân bằng. Bật JavaScript để thay đổi trọng số.

Chọn một hướng đi để xem chi tiết.

T4 Cassava starch to fermentation sugar hub 3.90

Feedstock enabler · enabler · 1 to 3 years

  • Market pull●●●●●
  • Vietnam advantage●●●●●
  • Technical readiness●●●●●
  • Route to market●●●●●
  • Capital efficiency●●●●●
  • Defensibility●●●●●
  • Public value●●●●●
Nội dung
Convert part of the cassava starch Vietnam exports into fermentation-grade glucose next to starch factories, and co-locate fermenters (domestic or foreign) at the same sites
Vì sao là Việt Nam
Vietnam shipped 2.15 Mt of cassava starch in 2023, 93.5% to China, while China imported only USD 0.16 million of glucose syrup from Vietnam in 2024; starch factories cluster in Tay Ninh and the Central Highlands; glucose technology is standard
Điều kiện cần đúng
Cassava prices stabilise after the 2025 to 2026 spike and the E10 mandate; at least one fermenter commits to co-locate; wastewater and biogas infrastructure can serve fermentation
Phép thử loại bỏ
No fermenter commits within two years; cassava price volatility makes long-term sugar contracts impossible
Khách hàng đầu tiên
Domestic food fermenters (yeast, enzymes, koji and fungal foods, amino acids for food); foreign biomass or precision-fermentation food firms seeking a lower-cost ASEAN site
Đối tác
Starch groups in Tay Ninh; provincial investment agencies; industrial parks
Thời gian
1 to 3 years
Vốn
Not estimated; hydrolysis and refining lines are standard starch-industry equipment
T1 Domestic textured plant protein 3.80

Plant protein · food ingredient · 0 to 2 years

  • Market pull●●●●●
  • Vietnam advantage●●●●●
  • Technical readiness●●●●●
  • Route to market●●●●●
  • Capital efficiency●●●●●
  • Defensibility●●●●●
  • Public value●●●●●
Nội dung
Dry textured soy protein and soy-gluten granules and slices, made in Vietnam for chay brands, frozen-food makers and co-packers; high-moisture whole cuts as a second step
Vì sao là Việt Nam
Every audited Vietnamese product with 10 g protein or more per 100 g runs on imported textured soy, soy protein or gluten; no commercial extrusion found; buyers named; ordinary food rules
Điều kiện cần đúng
Ex-factory cost at or below landed Chinese textured protein (USD 1.24/kg FOB in 2025; USD 1.29 to 1.38/kg landed; 0% duty under ACFTA and RCEP) (TIC-12; BUY-02; FTR-32); a food-grade, low-temperature defatted soy flour supply below the breakeven price (about USD 700 to 940 per t delivered for a 1 t/h line at 70% utilisation; our calculation, TIC-12; TIC-13); buyers value freshness, customisation and local supply
Phép thử loại bỏ
Delivered food-grade flour costs more than about USD 700 to 940 per t (1 t/h at 70%) or USD 590 to 900 per t (0.5 t/h at 70%); fewer than three buyers sign conditional orders totalling at least 2,000 t a year; Chinese landed price (USD 1.29 to 1.38/kg in 2025) stays below Vietnamese full cost at 2,800 t a year (0.5 t/h at 70%) or 5,600 t a year (1 t/h at 70%), on 8,000 operating hours a year; India-origin textured soy (USD 0.98/kg FOB in 2025) becomes the reference price; Version 0.10: no bank agrees to finance the supplier's receivables against the anchor buyer (supply-chain finance or factoring); without an anchor the working capital of USD 0.6 to 3.5 million has no named source
Khách hàng đầu tiên
An Nhien, Au Lac, Xuan Hong, LC Foods, Cholimex, CJ Foods Vietnam (Cau Tre, bibigo), Vissan, Thoai An, GN Foods and other co-packers
Đối tác
Extrusion-line suppliers; a soy crusher (VAL) for a food-grade flake stream; FIRI for pilot trials; Version 0.10, finance routes under Vietnamese law (instruments, not recommended providers): receivables finance or factoring against an anchor buyer (Circular 20/2024/TT-NHNN; banks such as BIDV run supply-chain finance for SMEs referred by an anchor company, up to 85% of order value); a finance lease or sale and leaseback of the line from a licensed leasing company (Circular 26/2024/TT-NHNN); and, for an SME owner, a guaranteed loan (the Ho Chi Minh City SME Credit Guarantee Fund caps guarantees at about VND 34 billion, about USD 1.3 million, per customer)
Thời gian
0 to 2 years
Vốn
Chinese dry-TVP lines of 0.5 to 1 t/h with dryer are listed at USD 11,000 to 100,000 (list prices, TIC-01 to TIC-10); installed capex in Vietnam USD 0.28 to 1.38 million (our calculation); working capital of USD 0.6 to 3.5 million is the larger need; a European-grade line is unverified (USD 2.0 to 5.6 million installed on the v0.1 equipment assumption of USD 1.5 to 4 million). Version 0.4: best owned by a chay maker, co-packer or distributor and financed with debt and trade finance, not venture equity; proposed score changes (capital efficiency 4 to 5, Vietnam advantage 3 to 2) recorded in play_demand_check.csv, scores here unchanged
T5 Shared pilot and tolling fermentation 3.45

Infrastructure enabler · enabler · 2 to 4 years

  • Market pull●●●●●
  • Vietnam advantage●●●●●
  • Technical readiness●●●●●
  • Route to market●●●●●
  • Capital efficiency●●●●●
  • Defensibility●●●●●
  • Public value●●●●●
Nội dung
A food-grade pilot line (hundreds of litres to a few cubic metres) plus negotiated tolling on existing industrial tanks, open to startups and researchers
Vì sao là Việt Nam
Aerobic tanks exist inside Vedan, Ajinomoto and Daesang, but we found no published tolling offer and no open pilot fermenter; startups otherwise scale up in Singapore, Thailand or China
Điều kiện cần đúng
An anchor host (industrial producer, Saigon Hi-Tech Park, FIRI or a university) and an operator; enough users to fill the line; public or DFI co-funding
Phép thử loại bỏ
No host agrees to tolling terms; utilisation below about a third in the first two years
Khách hàng đầu tiên
Food startups under T7 and T9; research groups; foreign firms testing Vietnamese feedstocks for food ingredients; Version 0.10: YERA (yeast protein, Nghe An) and Emmay (mushroom and mycelium foods) as likely domestic users, and university teaching capstones as an anchor user that fills line time (Berkeley precedent; not costed); ScaleUp Bio (Singapore) and EECi (Thailand) already compete for the same users
Đối tác
Saigon Hi-Tech Park; FIRI; Vedan; Ajinomoto; Daesang; Thai EECi (access arrangement)
Thời gian
2 to 4 years
Vốn
Pilot scale; public or DFI co-funding expected (not estimated) Version 0.10 benchmark: Metrosert (Estonia) is building an open, food-grade pilot plant with 50 L, 500 L and 5,000 L fermenters and drying, on a construction contract close to EUR 2 million (scope unclear; opening 2027)
T10 Mung bean and rice protein for plant drinks 3.05

Plant protein · food ingredient · 2 to 4 years

  • Market pull●●●●●
  • Vietnam advantage●●●●●
  • Technical readiness●●●●●
  • Route to market●●●●●
  • Capital efficiency●●●●●
  • Defensibility●●●●●
  • Public value●●●●●
Nội dung
Protein concentrates or isolates from mung bean and rice, replacing imported pea protein in high-protein plant drinks and yogurts
Vì sao là Việt Nam
A large plant-milk industry; imported pea protein in high-protein lines; rice and mung bean are familiar; ordinary food rules
Điều kiện cần đúng
Functional and sensory parity in drinks; cost near imported pea protein; a buyer specification; a reliable mung bean supply (65% of imports come from Myanmar); Version 0.10: raw material must fit the price. At 2023 to 2025 import prices, mung beans alone cost USD 3.0 to 4.9 per kg of isolate (60 to 80% protein recovery assumed), above Chinese pea protein at USD 2 to 3 per kg, so the line needs a paid starch co-product or a higher-priced job such as egg-white replacement (TPP-05); rice protein from broken rice costs USD 5.1 to 6.6 per kg of product in raw material alone, so the rice arm works only as a co-product of a rice syrup or starch line, and we found no such line in Vietnam (our calculation)
Phép thử loại bỏ
Buyer rejects on taste or stability; cost above imported pea protein by more than a local-sourcing premium buyers will pay; Version 0.10: no buyer for the mung bean starch co-product at a price that brings raw-material cost inside the TPP-05 band; for the rice arm, no rice syrup or starch host within two years
Khách hàng đầu tiên
Vinamilk, TH and other plant-milk makers
Đối tác
Rice millers; FIRI; food-technology faculties
Thời gian
2 to 4 years
Vốn
Moderate (wet fractionation and drying; not estimated)
T9 Koji and fungal foods on food-grade side streams 3.00

Fungal foods · food product · 1 to 3 years

  • Market pull●●●●●
  • Vietnam advantage●●●●●
  • Technical readiness●●●●●
  • Route to market●●●●●
  • Capital efficiency●●●●●
  • Defensibility●●●●●
  • Public value●●●●●
Nội dung
Solid-state fermented foods and ingredients using characterised Aspergillus oryzae or other food moulds on okara, broken rice or brewer's spent grain
Vì sao là Việt Nam
Tuong (fermented soybean paste) tradition; local gene tools for A. oryzae; koji on food substrates goes through ordinary self-declaration; food-grade side streams exist Version 0.10: a Vietnamese screen of yeasts from fermented foods found isolates with 62 to 67% protein in flasks, without safety data; koji mycelium deli meats from a Berkeley spin-out are sold commercially in the United States (USD 50 million raised by 2023)
Điều kiện cần đúng
A characterised strain with no cyclopiazonic acid or 3-nitropropionic acid risk; a food-grade substrate supply; consumer acceptance in chay and mainstream dishes
Phép thử loại bỏ
Strain safety data cannot be obtained; sensory trials fail with target buyers
Khách hàng đầu tiên
Chay brands; restaurants; frozen-food makers
Đối tác
VNU Hanoi fungal genetics group; tofu and soy-milk makers; breweries; Version 0.10: the Vietnam Type Culture Collection (VTCC) and Phenikaa University
Thời gian
1 to 3 years
Vốn
Low (solid-state fermentation rooms)
T7 High-value, low-dose precision-fermentation ingredients 2.10

Precision fermentation · food ingredient · 2 to 5 years

  • Market pull●●●●●
  • Vietnam advantage●●●●●
  • Technical readiness●●●●●
  • Route to market●●●●●
  • Capital efficiency●●●●●
  • Defensibility●●●●●
  • Public value●●●●●
Nội dung
Enzymes, heme or sweet proteins and specialty functional proteins developed by Vietnamese teams and made under contract (Singapore, Thailand, China) until a domestic option exists Version 0.10: low-dose flavour fats fit the same model (a Western brand has its fat made under contract by a Chinese microbial-oil producer); bulk fats do not (section 26.6)
Vì sao là Việt Nam
Vietnamese groups already express proteins in yeast; low-dose products escape the bulk-titer benchmark; export markets can rely on Singapore or other approvals
Điều kiện cần đúng
A product where titers of 1 to 10 g/L are economic; freedom to operate (OPENPichia or licensed strains); a foreign approval or an ingredient use outside novel-food rules; a clear GMO pathway under Decree 43/2026
Phép thử loại bỏ
No customer letter of intent after a sample programme; contract-manufacturing cost above the target price at pilot scale
Khách hàng đầu tiên
Regional food and flavour ingredient firms; specialty-nutrition makers
Đối tác
ScaleUp Bio (Singapore); EECi (Thailand); Chinese CDMOs; Vietnamese protein-expression labs
Thời gian
2 to 5 years
Vốn
Asset-light at first (contract manufacturing)
T8 Cultivated seafood research 1.55

Cultivated meat and seafood · research · 5 to 10 years or more

  • Market pull●●●●●
  • Vietnam advantage●●●●●
  • Technical readiness●●●●●
  • Route to market●●●●●
  • Capital efficiency●●●●●
  • Defensibility●●●●●
  • Public value●●●●●
Nội dung
Serum-free adaptation of striped catfish and shrimp cells, growth-factor expression and regulatory preparation, in partnership with foreign groups Version 0.10: research tasks now include low-cost hydrolysate media from Vietnamese soy, rice bran or fish by-products, because amino acids, not growth factors, are the larger medium cost in the published model (USD 19 against USD 3 per kg of cells at scale); candidate target species are Asian seabass or grouper, for which food-oriented muscle cell lines were published abroad in 2024 and 2025 (metadata only), with striped catfish as a low-cost model species and shrimp deferred until a continuous line exists
Vì sao là Việt Nam
Vietnam is the world's main pangasius producer; Vietnamese groups express growth factors and culture stem cells; regional approvals are arriving
Điều kiện cần đúng
A food-suitable cell line; research funding over 5 years or more; a partner with scale-up know-how; Version 0.10: the published cost model assumes an engineered cell line with efficient metabolism; that line must exist for a Vietnamese species
Phép thử loại bỏ
No serum-free, suspension-capable line after 3 years of work; Version 0.10: no hydrolysate-based medium supports fish-cell growth over several passages within three years
Khách hàng đầu tiên
None in this decade; research partners and foreign companies
Đối tác
Foreign cultivated-seafood firms; ICAR-NBFGR-type cell repositories; Vinh Hoan (a prior investor abroad); Version 0.10: holders of the grouper and Asian seabass muscle lines (Pukyong National University; Thiruvalluvar University; James Cook University Singapore) as foreign partners, with Nha Trang University or RIA3 as hosts; the Ho Chi Minh City University of Science tissue-engineering laboratory (cultured beef cells and a 3D-printed scaffold, press-reported in 2022)
Thời gian
5 to 10 years or more
Vốn
Research grants

Scores are judgements, not ratings. Candidate plays T11 and T12 are listed in section 26.8 but not ranked.

Bằng chứng Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.

Xem số liệuẨn số liệu
Seven plays, scored with weights you can change
RankPlayBalanced score (1 to 5)Horizon
1T4 Cassava starch to fermentation sugar hub3.901 to 3 years
2T1 Domestic textured plant protein3.800 to 2 years
3T5 Shared pilot and tolling fermentation3.452 to 4 years
4T10 Mung bean and rice protein for plant drinks3.052 to 4 years
5T9 Koji and fungal foods on food-grade side streams3.001 to 3 years
6T7 High-value, low-dose precision-fermentation ingredients2.102 to 5 years
7T8 Cultivated seafood research1.555 to 10 years or more
Top three under each preset
PresetFirstSecondThird
BalancedT4 (3.90)T1 (3.80)T5 (3.45)
InvestorsT1 (3.80)T4 (3.50)T5 and T9 (3.00)
Policy makersT4 (3.95)T5 (3.85)T1 (3.40)
StartupsT1 (4.15)T4 (3.85)T10 (3.25)
Food manufacturersT1 (4.15)T4 (3.75)T5 (3.20)
Research bodiesT4 (4.15)T5 (4.00)T1 (3.50)
International bodies and DFIsT4 (4.10)T5 (3.85)T1 (3.65)

Top three under each preset (our calculation).

PresetFirstSecondThird
BalancedT4 (3.90)T1 (3.80)T5 (3.45)
InvestorsT1 (3.80)T4 (3.50)T5 and T9 (3.00)
Policy makersT4 (3.95)T5 (3.85)T1 (3.40)
StartupsT1 (4.15)T4 (3.85)T10 (3.25)
ManufacturersT1 (4.15)T4 (3.75)T5 (3.20)
Research bodiesT4 (4.15)T5 (4.00)T1 (3.50)
International bodies and DFIsT4 (4.10)T5 (3.85)T1 (3.65)

Reading. T1 and T4 are in the top three under every preset; T5 under five of seven. T4 scores highly because it carries little technical or legal risk and uses Vietnam's clearest advantage. Its weak point is that no fermenter has yet agreed to buy the sugar. T5 rises when public value counts more. T7 and T8 stay at the bottom: not worthless, but not near-term plays for Vietnam.

26.3 The plays

T1. Domestic textured plant protein

  • What. Dry textured soy and soy-gluten pieces, made in Vietnam for chay (vegetarian food) brands, frozen-food makers and co-packers. Whole-cut products come later.
  • Why Vietnam. Every audited Vietnamese product with 10 g of protein or more per 100 g runs on imported soy or gluten, much of it from China. Nobody in Vietnam makes textured soy, and ordinary food rules apply1,2,3,4Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. There is no tariff shelter: Chinese and Southeast Asian product enters duty-free5Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. The import pool a line can serve is up to about 12,800 t a year6,7Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..
  • What has to be true. Factory cost at or below the Chinese landed price, about USD 1.29 to 1.38 per kg (our calculation)7,6Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. Food-grade soy flour delivered below about USD 700 to 940 per t. Buyers who value freshness, custom products and local supply.
  • Kill tests. T1 fails if flour costs more than that; if fewer than three buyers sign conditional orders for 2,000 t a year; if Chinese or cheaper Indian product stays below Vietnamese cost; or if no bank will finance the supplier against an anchor buyer8,9Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..
  • First customers. Chay makers and frozen-food makers such as An Nhien, Au Lac, Xuan Hong, LC Foods, Cholimex, CJ Foods Vietnam, Vissan and Thoai An, and co-packers such as GN Foods1,10Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. Smaller chay makers can be reached through ingredient distributors11,12,13Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..
  • Partners and finance. Extrusion-line suppliers; a soy crusher for food-grade flour14; the national food research institute for trials; and a bank. Vietnam already offers invoice finance against an anchor buyer, equipment leases, and loan guarantees for small firms of up to about USD 1.3 million15,9,16,17,18Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc..
  • Horizon and capital. 0 to 2 years. Chinese lines list at USD 11,000 to 100,00019,20,21Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu.. Installed in Vietnam, a line costs USD 0.28 to 1.38 million, and working capital of USD 0.6 to 3.5 million is the larger need (our calculation; Economics).

T4. Cassava starch to fermentation sugar hub

  • What. Turn part of the cassava starch Vietnam exports into fermentation-grade glucose next to the starch factories, and put food fermenters on the same site.
  • Why Vietnam. Vietnam shipped 2.15 Mt of cassava starch in 2023, mostly to China, but almost no glucose22,23Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc.. Starch factories cluster in Tay Ninh and the Central Highlands (Asset map).
  • What has to be true. Cassava prices settle after the 2025 to 2026 spike and the fuel-ethanol mandate24,25,26Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. At least one fermenter agrees to locate on the site.
  • Kill tests. No fermenter commits within two years, or cassava price swings rule out long-term sugar contracts.
  • First customers. Domestic food fermenters (yeast, enzymes, koji, amino acids), and foreign fermentation firms seeking a cheaper Southeast Asian site (Region).
  • Horizon and capital. 1 to 3 years. Standard starch-industry equipment; Vedan already built large glucose capacity27Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..

T5. Shared pilot and tolling fermentation

  • What. A food-grade pilot line, from hundreds of litres to a few cubic metres, plus rented time on existing industrial tanks, open to startups and researchers.
  • Why Vietnam. Large air-fed tanks exist inside Vedan, Ajinomoto and Daesang, but we found no rental offer and no open pilot fermenter (Industrial base)28,29,30,31,32Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu..
  • What has to be true. A host and an operator; enough users; public or development co-funding.
  • Kill tests. No host accepts rental terms, or use stays below a third of capacity in the first two years.
  • First customers. Food startups such as YERA (yeast protein) and Emmay (mushroom foods); research groups; foreign firms testing Vietnamese raw materials33,34Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu.. University teaching can also fill line time35Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. Singapore's and Thailand's pilot plants compete for the same users36,37Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..
  • Partners. Saigon Hi-Tech Park38, the national food research institute, the amino-acid makers, and an access deal with Thailand's public pilot plant37.
  • Horizon and capital. 2 to 4 years; not estimated for Vietnam. An Estonian open food-grade pilot plant with tanks up to 5,000 L has a building contract near EUR 2 million39Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu..

T7. High-value, low-dose precision-fermentation ingredients

  • What. Enzymes, heme or sweet proteins and specialty proteins developed by Vietnamese teams and made under contract abroad until a domestic option exists. Flavour fats used in small doses fit the same model40Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..
  • Why Vietnam. Vietnamese groups already make proteins in yeast (Knowledge and talent). Low-dose products escape the yield problem of bulk protein (our inference)41,42Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc..
  • What has to be true. A product that pays at low yields; freedom to operate43; a foreign approval or a use outside novel-food rules; a clear GMO route (Rules).
  • Kill tests. No customer letter of intent after samples, or contract-making cost above the target price.
  • Partners. Contract manufacturers in Singapore, Thailand or China36,37,44Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..
  • Horizon and capital. 2 to 5 years; few fixed assets at first.

T8. Cultivated seafood research

  • What. Research with foreign partners on growing fish cells without serum, on growth factors and on regulation. Two tasks lead:
    • Cheap growth media from Vietnamese soy, rice bran or fish by-products. Amino acids are the largest medium cost, and the author of the main cost model says suitable cheap media "do not exist today"45Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc..
    • Species. Food-oriented cell lines exist abroad for grouper and Asian seabass, both farmed in Vietnam. We read only their titles and authors, so this is a candidate choice46,47,48Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu.. Catfish is a cheap model species; shrimp waits for a true cell line49,50Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc..
  • Why Vietnam. Vietnam exports about USD 2.2 billion of pangasius a year, and has groups working on growth factors and stem cells (Knowledge and talent)51,52,53Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu..
  • Kill tests. No serum-free line that grows in suspension after three years, or no cheap medium that supports fish cells.
  • Partners. Holders of the grouper and seabass lines, with Nha Trang University or a national aquaculture institute as hosts54Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu..
  • Horizon and capital. 5 to 10 years or more; research grants.

T9. Koji and fungal foods on food-grade side streams

  • What. Fermented foods and ingredients made with characterised koji mould or other food moulds, grown on okara (soy pulp), broken rice or brewer's spent grain.
  • Why Vietnam. A tương (fermented soybean paste) tradition, and local genetic tools for koji mould55,56Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. Koji on food ingredients goes through ordinary self-declaration (Rules). A national culture collection holds over 15,000 strains57,58Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. Koji-based deli meats sell in the US59Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..
  • What has to be true. A strain proven free of mould toxins60Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc.; steady food-grade side streams; acceptance in chay and everyday dishes.
  • Kill tests. Strain safety data cannot be obtained, or taste trials fail with target buyers.
  • Partners. The national culture collection; Phenikaa University; tofu makers and breweries. Characterised strains are candidate public good P7 (section 26.8).
  • Horizon and capital. 1 to 3 years; low.

T10. Mung bean and rice protein for plant drinks

  • What. Concentrates or isolates from mung bean and rice, replacing imported pea protein in high-protein plant drinks and yoghurts.
  • Why Vietnam. A large plant-milk industry. Vinamilk's high-protein line uses pea protein, which nobody makes in Vietnam1Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu..
  • What has to be true. Taste and function as good as pea; cost near imported pea protein; a buyer specification; reliable mung bean supply, mostly imported from Myanmar61; honest protein-quality claims62Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc..
  • Raw material must fit the price. Mung beans alone cost USD 3.0 to 4.9 per kg of isolate, above Chinese pea protein at USD 2 to 3 (our calculation)63,64Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. So a mung bean line needs a paid buyer for its starch, or a better-paid job such as replacing egg white (Demand to frontier). Rice protein pays only as a by-product of a rice syrup or starch line, and we found none in Vietnam65,66Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..
  • Kill tests. The buyer rejects it on taste or stability; it costs far more than imported pea; no buyer for the starch; no rice host within two years.
  • First customers. Vinamilk, TH and other plant-milk makers. A cheap first test is a buyer-sponsored university project67Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..
  • Horizon and capital. 2 to 4 years; moderate.

When each play could deliver

Years from now to first commercial result

When each play could deliverGantt bars for seven plays: textured protein 0 to 2 years; sugar hub and koji 1 to 3; pilot fermentation and plant-drink proteins 2 to 4; precision fermentation 2 to 5; cultivated seafood 5 to 10 or more.Food ingredientEnablerResearchFood product012345678910Years from now to first commercial resultT1 Domestic textured plant proteinT1 Domestic textured plant protein: 0 to 2 years Segment: food ingredient Capital: Chinese dry-TVP lines of 0.5 to 1 t/h with dryer are listed at USD 11,000 to 100,000 (list prices, TIC-01 to TIC-10); installed capex in Vietnam USD 0.28 to 1.38 million (our calculation); working capital of USD 0.6 to 3.5 million is the larger need; a European-grade line is unverified (USD 2.0 to 5.6 million installed on the v0.1 equipment assumption of USD 1.5 to 4 million). Version 0.4: best owned by a chay maker, co-packer or distributor and financed with debt and trade finance, not venture equity; proposed score changes (capital efficiency 4 to 5, Vietnam advantage 3 to 2) recorded in play_demand_check.csv, scores here unchanged First customers: An Nhien, Au Lac, Xuan Hong, LC Foods, Cholimex, CJ Foods Vietnam (Cau Tre, bibigo), Vissan, Thoai An, GN Foods and other co-packers0 to 2 yearsT4 Cassava starch to fermentation sugarhubT4 Cassava starch to fermentation sugar hub: 1 to 3 years Segment: enabler Capital: Not estimated; hydrolysis and refining lines are standard starch-industry equipment First customers: Domestic food fermenters (yeast, enzymes, koji and fungal foods, amino acids for food); foreign biomass or precision-fermentation food firms seeking a lower-cost ASEAN site1 to 3 yearsT9 Koji and fungal foods on food-gradeside streamsT9 Koji and fungal foods on food-grade side streams: 1 to 3 years Segment: food product Capital: Low (solid-state fermentation rooms) First customers: Chay brands; restaurants; frozen-food makers1 to 3 yearsT5 Shared pilot and tolling fermentationT5 Shared pilot and tolling fermentation: 2 to 4 years Segment: enabler Capital: Pilot scale; public or DFI co-funding expected (not estimated) Version 0.10 benchmark: Metrosert (Estonia) is building an open, food-grade pilot plant with 50 L, 500 L and 5,000 L fermenters and drying, on a construction contract close to EUR 2 million (scope unclear; opening 2027) First customers: Food startups under T7 and T9; research groups; foreign firms testing Vietnamese feedstocks for food ingredients; Version 0.10: YERA (yeast protein, Nghe An) and Emmay (mushroom and mycelium foods) as likely domestic users, and university teaching capstones as an anchor user that fills line time (Berkeley precedent; not costed); ScaleUp Bio (Singapore) and EECi (Thailand) already compete for the same users2 to 4 yearsT10 Mung bean and rice protein for plantdrinksT10 Mung bean and rice protein for plant drinks: 2 to 4 years Segment: food ingredient Capital: Moderate (wet fractionation and drying; not estimated) First customers: Vinamilk, TH and other plant-milk makers2 to 4 yearsT7 High-value, low-doseprecision-fermentation ingredientsT7 High-value, low-dose precision-fermentation ingredients: 2 to 5 years Segment: food ingredient Capital: Asset-light at first (contract manufacturing) First customers: Regional food and flavour ingredient firms; specialty-nutrition makers2 to 5 yearsT8 Cultivated seafood researchT8 Cultivated seafood research: 5 to 10 years or more Segment: research Capital: Research grants First customers: None in this decade; research partners and foreign companies5 to 10 years or more

Bằng chứng Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.

Xem số liệuẨn số liệu
When each play could deliver
PlayNameSegmentHorizonStart (years)End (years)
T1Domestic textured plant proteinfood ingredient0 to 2 years02
T4Cassava starch to fermentation sugar hubenabler1 to 3 years13
T9Koji and fungal foods on food-grade side streamsfood product1 to 3 years13
T5Shared pilot and tolling fermentationenabler2 to 4 years24
T10Mung bean and rice protein for plant drinksfood ingredient2 to 4 years24
T7High-value, low-dose precision-fermentation ingredientsfood ingredient2 to 5 years25
T8Cultivated seafood researchresearch5 to 10 years or more510

26.4 Four public goods

These are not businesses. They lower the cost and risk of every play, and most are cheap (Policy options).

IDPublic goodWhat it unlocksPolicy options
P1Proportionate new-food procedureT7, T9 and food uses of fungal proteinPO-015, PO-019
P4Protein-quality and function laboratoryT1, T9, T10, and any novel-food application(Policy options)
P5Yearly by-product atlas (volume, location, price, composition)T4, T9(Policy options)
P6Open cost model and public price series for protein ingredientsAll fermentation plays; investor screening(Policy options)

Three details from the solutions screen:

  • P1. For cultivated food, a 2023 international safety framework from FAO and the World Health Organization, alongside Singapore's approvals, gives a ready basis for relying on trusted regulators68,69,70Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..
  • P4 should test function as well as quality: solubility, binding, foaming and gelling, which buyers specify. We found no such testing service in Vietnam71Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu.. An open method guide already exists72Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc..
  • P6 can start from an open global cost dataset, so effort can go to Vietnamese inputs and a domestic price series, including farm-gate bean prices73,74,75Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..

26.5 Sequencing: a portfolio view

  • Now to 2028. T1 as a debt-financed plant owned by an established firm; T4 if a fermenter commits; T9 as a small pilot; P1 through the Food Safety Law; T5 designed and funded.
  • 2028 to 2031. T5 running; T10 if a drinks buyer writes a specification; T7 through contract manufacturing.
  • 2031 onward. T8 if a food cell line exists and a regional approval route works.

26.6 What we do not recommend, and why

Feed-ingredient plays are retired

The study concentrates on protein for people, so we no longer treat feed ingredients as something to make. That is why play and public-good numbers have gaps. We also do not recommend replacing soybean meal in pig and poultry feed with fermentation protein: the price gap is about five times (Economics).

Other routes we do not recommend

  • Premium imported-style meat copies as a first business. They cost ten times more than chicken and egg protein (Alt protein today, Economics).
  • Commodity precision-fermented dairy or egg proteins made in Vietnam. Yields, rules and missing infrastructure all point the other way (Technology fit).
  • Cultivated-meat production. No cell line, no legal route, and costs 15 to 29 times the shop price of pork or chicken (our calculation)45,76,77Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu..
  • Bulk fats made by fermentation. Even an ideal plant would cost more than palm oil78,79,40Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..
  • Cultivated or fermentation-made surimi. Vietnamese surimi sells for about USD 2 per kg, far below any cultivated cost80,81,45Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. A plant-protein blend is the only surimi route we propose (T11, section 26.8).

26.7 What this means

  • Investors: T1 is near-term, but as bank debt and trade finance for a plant owned by an established firm, not a venture thesis. The anchor buyer matters most for working capital16,15,9Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. T4 needs a strategic partner and development capital. Use the kill tests as diligence questions, starting with a delivered flour quote.
  • Startups: T1 and T9 can earn revenue under today's rules. Write the buyer specification before building the plant. For T1, bring in a chay maker or distributor as co-owner or anchor buyer.
  • Manufacturers: you are the natural owner of T1 and the first customer for T10. The cheapest start is pooled orders from two or three chay makers behind one line, through separate supply contracts or a cooperative. Competing makers must not agree among themselves on the price they pay, which competition law bans (our reading, not legal advice)82,83Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..
  • Policy makers: P1 costs little and unlocks several plays. T4 and T5 are where investment promotion can act.
  • Researchers: T8, T9 and the public goods P4 to P6 are research-led.
  • International bodies: T4 and T5 fit development finance and technical help.

26.8 Three candidates from the solutions screen

We screened 170 published solutions for Vietnam, including all 112 entries of the Good Food Institute's solutions database. Most were already covered by the plays above, or were frontier work Vietnam would buy rather than make. None displaces T1, T4 or T5.

Three candidates came out of the screen. We show their scores for comparison but do not rank them yet. Each still has to pass a test the active plays have passed.

IDCandidateMarketAdvantageReadinessRouteCapitalDefensibilityPublic valueBalanced scoreTest before ranking
T11Hybrid fish cakes and fish balls23455233.50A maker trial and a taste panel at 10% to 30% plant protein
T12Domestic food-grade soybean and mung bean32454243.50A farm-economics test and conditional buyer contracts
P7Characterised Vietnamese food-strain setA host collection agrees standard licence terms, and three firms ask for strains

Source: AltProtein Vietnam scoringBằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu..

T11. Hybrid fish cakes and fish balls.

  • The idea. Fish-cake makers replace 10% to 30% of the fish protein with plant protein, and print the fish share.
  • Why Vietnam. Surimi and fish-cake exports passed USD 344 million in 202584Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. The wild catch is planned to fall from 3.83 Mt to 2.8 Mt by 2030, and exporters already report shortages85,86,87,88Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc. Hướng tới tương lai: dự phóng, kết quả mô hình đã công bố hoặc mục tiêu chính thức.. Plant protein costs 3.6 to 7.5 times less than surimi per kg of protein (our calculation)80Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu.. It needs no new plant.
  • Why it is not ranked. Its score comes from ease of entry, not demand. Taste panels abroad rejected blends above 30% to 40%, and a leading Korean maker is moving to 80% fish or more89,90Bằng chứng: bằng chứng chung, không riêng Việt Nam (general); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..

T12. Domestic food-grade soybean and mung bean.

  • The idea. Contract-grown, non-GM, food-grade beans for soy milk, tofu and plant drinks.
  • Why Vietnam. Soy foods carry about 181,000 t of protein a year on beans that are 97.5% imported91Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc.. Returning to the 2010 soybean area would cover most food soybean use (our calculation)74,92Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu.. It is the one route we found that raises the domestic share of protein people already eat at that scale.
  • The constraint. Domestic beans cost about 1.4 to 2.3 times imports74,75,93Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy thấp: một nhận định đơn lẻ, báo chí, tiếp thị của doanh nghiệp hoặc suy ra từ dữ liệu yếu..

P7. Characterised Vietnamese food-strain set.

  • The idea. Sequence and screen 20 to 50 moulds and yeasts already used in Vietnamese ferments, and supply them on one standard licence.
  • Why it matters. It removes T9's first kill test, strain safety.
  • Why now. Access licences now take about 19 working days, though benefit sharing still applies94Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy cao: đã đọc nguồn gốc.. We found no study on the safety of Vietnamese food strains95Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..

Related: Demand to frontier, Policy options, Investors, Startups, Food manufacturers.

Nguồn được trích dẫn trong trang

Các số trong bài dẫn đến danh sách này. Mọi nguồn cũng có trong danh sách nguồn đầy đủ. Danh sách nguồn đầy đủ

  1. FORM-01AltProtein Vietnam. AltProtein Vietnam retail field audit, Nha Trang 6 Sep 2026 and Ho Chi Minh City 16 and 20 Sep 2026, 186 SKUs, 11 stores. 6 to 20 Sep 2026
  2. FORM-02World Bank WITS / UN Comtrade. Vietnam Protein concentrates and textured protein subst imports by country, 2023. 2023
  3. FORM-05World Bank WITS / UN Comtrade. China Protein concentrates and textured protein subst exports by country, 2023. 2023
  4. FORM-11Phụ Gia Việt Mỹ (VMC Group). Top 3 địa chỉ phân phối đạm đậu nành uy tín chính hãng
  5. FTR-32Ministry of Industry and Trade. Vietnam National Trade Repository: tariff schedules. accessed 2026-09-25
  6. BUY-02United Nations Statistics Division (UN Comtrade). Exports to Vietnam of protein ingredients by reporter, 2019 to 2025 (mirror data). 2019 to 2025 data; queried 2026-09-24
  7. TIC-12United Nations Statistics Division (UN Comtrade). China exports to Vietnam of soy flour, soybean meal, textured protein, gluten and other proteins, 2023 to 2025. 2026
  8. SLK-18International Finance Corporation. IFC, SECO strengthen partnership to bolster supply chain finance market in Viet Nam. 2025-03-17
  9. SLK-19Vietnam Banks Association (BIDV release). BIDV SCFast 2026: Giải pháp toàn diện hỗ trợ doanh nghiệp trong chuỗi cung ứng. 2026-01-16
  10. CPC-15Saigon Co.op (Co.op Online). Co.op Select product pages. 2026-09
  11. TIC-18General Department of Customs (Tong cuc Hai quan). Notice 4816/TB-TCHQ on advance classification of SUPRO MAX 5013IP. 2024-10-04
  12. BUY-36VMC Group. Gluten lua mi Xinrui (Trung Quoc) bao 25kg. accessed 2026-09-24
  13. BUY-37TDGIMEX. Vital wheat gluten, gluten lua mi, bot mi can. accessed 2026-09-24
  14. FORM-10Dân Trí. TPHCM có tổ hợp ép dầu đậu nành quy mô hàng đầu Đông Nam Á. 10 Dec 2025
  15. SLK-05State Bank of Vietnam (translation by LuatVietnam). Circular 20/2024/TT-NHNN on factoring. 2024-06-28
  16. SLK-01State Bank of Vietnam (translation by LuatVietnam). Circular 26/2024/TT-NHNN on financial leasing activities. 2024-06-28
  17. SLK-24VnEconomy (English). Financial leasing encouraged for green growth. 2025-08-04
  18. SLK-20Ho Chi Minh City People's Committee (via LuatVietnam). Quyết định 3204/QĐ-UBND năm 2026 ban hành Điều lệ tổ chức và hoạt động của Quỹ Bảo lãnh tín dụng cho các doanh nghiệp nhỏ và vừa Thành phố Hồ Chí Minh. 2026-05-29
  19. TIC-02Jinan Sunward Machinery Co., Ltd.. Turnkey Twin-Screw Textured Soy Protein Tsp Tvp Project Processing Line. 2026
  20. TIC-03Jinan Saibainuo Extrusion Machinery Co., Ltd.. Tvp Tsp Fiber Artificial Vegetable Meat Production Plant. 2026
  21. TIC-07Shandong Joyang Machinery Co., Ltd.. Tvp Tsp Textured Vegetable Soy Protein Soya Chunks Nuggets Minces Making Machine. 2026
  22. RGN-53Vietnam exports HS 110814 by partner. World Bank WITS. 2023
  23. RGN-55China imports HS 170230 (glucose) by partner. World Bank WITS. 2024
  24. FS-08Stockbiz. Sắn vào chu kỳ giá: [Bài cuối] Ethanol tạo động lực mới. 7 August 2026
  25. FS-11Nông nghiệp và Môi trường. Nguồn cung giảm mạnh, giá sắn gần gấp đôi cùng kỳ 2025. 9 April 2026
  26. FS-12Doanh nghiệp và Đầu tư. Thị trường sắn quý I/2026: giá tăng, xuất khẩu bứt phá nhưng tiềm ẩn rủi ro. 2 April 2026
  27. VCO-03Vedan International. Milestones. undated
  28. VCO-05Vedan Vietnam. Vedan Vietnam, home page. undated
  29. IND-08CafeBiz. Ajinomoto muon tang manh cong suat mang thuc an chan nuoi, phan bon va gia vi long tai Viet Nam. 4 December 2023
  30. IND-11Daesang Vietnam. About Daesang Vietnam (history, plants)
  31. INF-02FIRI. FIRI, Food Production Pilot and Technology Transfer Center (FTET) page. undated
  32. INF-05HCMC Biotechnology Center, technology transfer services list. undated
  33. RDL-01TheLeader. Startup protein men vi sinh tu bo 100 ty dong khoi nghiep (YERA on Shark Tank Vietnam). 2024
  34. AIS-39We-Fi. Pioneering Sustainable Agri-Tech and Plant-Based Proteins from Vietnam. 2025-12-15
  35. AML-32College of Chemistry, UC Berkeley. Bioprocess Engineering Program Description
  36. RGN-10ScaleUp Bio. ScaleUp Bio, home page
  37. RGN-36EECi. Biorefinery Pilot Plant
  38. INF-06SHTP Management Board. Saigon Hi-Tech Park, home page (units, area, projects). undated
  39. SLF-11vegconomist. Metrosert opens Estonia's fermentation bottleneck with EUR 2M pilot plant. 2026-07-24
  40. SLF-09AgFunder News. Fats from fermentation: Nourish Ingredients and CABIO Biotech announce strategic biomanufacturing partnership. 2024-11-11
  41. SCI-01Nielsen MB, Meyer AS, Arnau J. The Next Food Revolution Is Here: Recombinant Microbial Production of Milk and Egg Proteins by Precision Fermentation. 2024
  42. SCI-05Chen H et al. Integrated Fermentation Engineering Enables High-Level Leghemoglobin Production in Kluyveromyces marxianus. 2026
  43. SCI-08Claes K et al. OPENPichia: licence-free Komagataella phaffii chassis strains and toolkit for protein expression. 2024
  44. RGN-24van der Kley, D. China Biomanufacturing Study Report. 31 Jul 2026
  45. COST-47Humbird D. Scale-up economics for cultured meat. 2021
  46. SLS-14Krishnan S. et al. (Pukyong National University). Establishment, characterization, and sensory characteristics of an immortalized muscle cell line from the seven-band grouper. 2024
  47. SLS-15Mithra S. et al. (Thiruvalluvar University). Production of small-scale laboratory-grown cell-based fish meat from Asian seabass muscle and fin cell lines. 2025
  48. SLS-16Mithra S. et al. (Thiruvalluvar University). Production of cell culture-based micro-tissue from muscle and fin cell lines of Lates calcarifer using biocompatible scaffolds. 2025
  49. SCI-10Soni P, Pradhan PK, Sood N et al. Development, characterization and in vitro applications of a thymus cell line from Pangasianodon hypophthalmus. 2023
  50. SCI-12Anoop BS, Puthumana J et al. Immortalization of shrimp lymphoid cells by hybridizing with the continuous cell line Sf9 leading to the development of 'PmLyO-Sf9'. 2021
  51. MAC-01USDA FAS GAIN. Vietnam: Grain and Feed Annual, report VM2026-0012. 15 Apr 2026
  52. SLC-01Tuoi Tre News. Vietnam conducts research on lab-grown meat. 2022-12-12
  53. CAP-16Bao Dau Tu. Dau tu vao start-up nuoc ngoai, Vinh Hoan huong den hai san, thit duoc nuoi cay tu te bao. 2021
  54. SLS-13OpenAlex (OurResearch). OpenAlex queries: fish cell lines by Vietnamese farmed species. 2026-10-15
  55. RD-33Thai H.-D. et al. Development of a new Agrobacterium-mediated transformation system based on a dual auxotrophic approach in Aspergillus oryzae. 2021
  56. RD-34Trinh M.T. et al. Efficient generation of uridine/uracil auxotrophic mutants in homokaryotic Cordyceps militaris strains for constructing a food-grade expression platform. 2024
  57. SLF-01Institute of Microbiology and Biotechnology, Vietnam National University, Hanoi. Trung tâm Nguồn gen Vi sinh vật Quốc gia (VTCC). undated
  58. SLF-04Phenikaa University (Vietnam Journal of Food Control, NIFC). Potential for single cell protein production by yeast isolated from fermented foods. 2026
  59. AML-29Just Food. Monde Nissin joins Prime Roots $30m financing for fungi-based charcuterie. 2023-05-15
  60. SCI-19Frisvad JC et al. Safety of the fungal workhorses of industrial biotechnology. 2018
  61. FORM-08World Bank WITS / UN Comtrade. Vietnam imports of HS 071331 (dried mung/black gram beans) by country, 2023. 2023
  62. SCI-42Shivakumar N et al. Protein-quality evaluation of complementary foods in Indian children. 2019
  63. SLP-14United Nations Statistics Division. UN Comtrade HS 071331 trade with Vietnam, 2023 to 2025. 2026-10-15
  64. BUY-09Volza. Pea Protein Imports in Vietnam. accessed 2026-09-24
  65. SLP-08National Taiwan University. Feasibility of preparing rice protein from broken rice. 2019
  66. SLP-01Can Tho University; Nguyen Tat Thanh University (MDPI Foods). The optimization of Viscozyme-assisted hydrolysis to enhance protein extraction from VD20 broken rice. 2026-04-07
  67. AML-05Alt: Meat Lab, Sutardja Center for Entrepreneurship and Technology (SCET), UC Berkeley. Amid COVID-19, the Alt: Meat Lab continues its research. 2020-08-10
  68. SLC-05FAO and WHO. Food safety aspects of cell-based food. 2023
  69. SLC-06Food Safety News (J. Whitworth). FAO and WHO consider the safety of cell-based food. 2023-04-06
  70. RGN-04Singapore Food Agency. SFA list of approved novel foods. 14 Aug 2026
  71. SLP-17TTech Vietnam. Thiet bi kiem tra texture TA1 Ametek. 2026
  72. SLP-10Embrapa Agroindustria de Alimentos (Brazilian Agricultural Research Corporation). Guide for technological functional characterization of protein ingredients for the plant-based market. 2022
  73. SLF-10The Good Food Institute; Hawkwood Biotech. Techno-economic insights on fermentation ingredients. 2025
  74. AQF-20VnEconomy. Ngành đậu tương có nhiều 'nút thắt' cần tháo gỡ. 7 Nov 2024
  75. SEC-05United Nations Statistics Division (UN Comtrade). Viet Nam imports of protein-relevant HS lines by partner, 2023. 2026-10-01
  76. COST-39Pork category. Bach Hoa Xanh (online)
  77. COST-40Chicken category. Bach Hoa Xanh (online)
  78. SLF-08University of Bath. Using techno-economic modelling to determine the minimum cost possible for a microbial palm oil substitute. 2021
  79. FM-01World Bank. Commodity Price Data (The Pink Sheet). 2 Sep 2026
  80. SLS-05United Nations Statistics Division. UN Comtrade annual trade data (preview API). 2026-10-15
  81. GSD-01Good Food Institute. Solutions Database. 2021 to 2025
  82. SLK-08National Assembly of Vietnam (translation by LuatVietnam). Law on Competition 23/2018/QH14. 2018-06-12
  83. SLK-09National Assembly of Vietnam (translation by LuatVietnam). Law on Cooperatives 17/2023/QH15. 2023-06-20
  84. SLS-01Báo Đại biểu Nhân dân (data attributed to VASEP). Xuất khẩu surimi và chả cá tiếp tục khởi sắc. 2026-02-20
  85. MAC-15NSO. Thuy san Viet Nam quy IV va ca nam 2025: Giu da tang truong, vuot thach thuc, huong toi phat trien ben vung. 8 Jan 2026
  86. NTS-08Prime Minister. Quyết định 339/QĐ-TTg, Chiến lược phát triển thủy sản Việt Nam đến năm 2030, tầm nhìn 2045. 11 Mar 2021
  87. SLS-04VASEP. Many factors hinder recovery of Vietnam's surimi exports. 2024-05-22
  88. SLS-03VASEP. Vietnam's surimi industry needs more efforts. 2024-01-19
  89. SLS-07Ye T. et al. (Hefei University of Technology, Jiangnan University). Masterly substitution of plant proteins can achieve acceptable sensory and nutritional attributes in meat-reduced surimi gel. 2024-08-22
  90. SLS-11Herald Corporation. Dongwon F&B second Jincheon plant. 2026-06-15
  91. DIE-07FAO. FAOSTAT Food Balance Sheets. 2025-10-14
  92. AIB-06QNS. Báo cáo thường niên 2025. 2026-03
  93. PPE-05The Protein Project. Towards a Legume Renaissance in Europe. 2026-02
  94. SLF-02Government of Viet Nam. Nghị định 43/2026/NĐ-CP sửa đổi, bổ sung một số điều của các nghị định trong lĩnh vực bảo tồn thiên nhiên và đa dạng sinh học. 2026-01-26
  95. SLF-03OpenAlex. OpenAlex searches: microbes of Vietnamese fermented foods (15 October 2026). 2026-10-15