AltProtein VietnamProtein thay thế tại Việt NamNghiên cứu xác định phạm vi phía cung · Phiên bản 1.0

Chương 30Phần V: Nên làm gì?

30. What we do not know, and who can tell us

Nội dung trang này bằng tiếng Anh.

Trong trang này
  1. 30.1 The eighteen unknowns that matter most
  2. 30.2 Where sources disagree
  3. 30.3 Limits of this report
  4. 30.4 How to help close the gaps

In brief

  • We built this report from public sources over thirteen research rounds. By the end, each new search added little.
  • The remaining gaps sit in ministry files, company plants and customs records, not on the open web. Most can be closed cheaply: a written question to a ministry, a call to a factory or food maker, or a customs data request.
  • We list the eighteen unknowns that matter most, ranked by how much each would change a decision in this report, with who to ask.
  • Four decide how far the security case reaches: where the inputs of Vietnamese alternative-protein foods come from, how much of the soy in tofu is Vietnamese, whether any agency compiles a food balance, and whether a swine fever vaccine protects against the new strains.

30.1 The eighteen unknowns that matter most

The "Unblocks" column uses the play codes of Plays and the move codes of Moves for any 2050: T1 textured plant protein; T4 cassava sugar hub; T5 shared pilot and tolling fermentation; T7 high-value precision fermentation; T10 mung bean and rice protein for drinks; P1 new-food procedure; P4 protein-quality laboratory; RM-01 national protein balance. "Security case" is the first argument in Why Vietnam, section 1.6.

#UnknownUnblocksWho to ask, or the cheapest way to close it
1Does the draft Food Safety Law define "new food", or delegate it to the Government?P1 and all food playsThe National Assembly's draft portal; the Vietnam Food Administration
2Do purified precision-fermented proteins need a GMO food certificate? What are the timeline and fee for making them in Vietnam?T7A written question to the agriculture ministry and the Vietnam Food Administration
3Will Vedan, Ajinomoto or Daesang rent tank time to others, and how much is idle?T5A direct question to their planning teams
4Does anyone extrude textured soy in Vietnam?T1Ask chay makers and ingredient distributors
5Import volumes of textured protein, soy isolate and gluten at the finest tariff levelT1Customs statistics or a trade-data service
6The factory-gate price and use of cassava pulpT4Calls to three to five starch factories in Tay Ninh; the cassava association
7Current prices of cassava starch, glucose syrup and molassesT4Cassava and sugar associations; starch factories
8Where does the protein in Vietnamese alternative-protein foods come from: domestic or imported inputs?T1; security caseCustoms data by importer; calls to three textured-soy and chay makers
9What share of the soybeans in tofu and soy milk is grown in Vietnam?Security case; RM-01Vinasoy and a large tofu maker or bean trader
10Does any Vietnamese agency compile a national food or protein balance?RM-01One call to the statistics office and the agriculture ministry
11Is a swine fever vaccine that protects against the new strains in trials or licensing?Security case (disease)Vietnamese vaccine makers; the ministry's licensing lists
12Which Vietnamese laboratories are accredited for amino-acid and digestibility tests?P4, T1, T10The main food laboratories; the accreditation body
13How much cooling energy does a Vietnamese fermentation plant use?All fermentation playsEngineers at Vedan, Ajinomoto or AB Mauri
14Can a product made in Vietnam be sold in Singapore under a Singapore approval?T7; the 2035 regional hub (Outlook)The Singapore Food Agency's import rules
15ScaleUp Bio's capacity, prices and willingness to take Vietnamese clientsT5, T7ScaleUp Bio (Singapore)
16Is Thailand's public pilot plant food-grade, and on what terms for foreign clients?T5, T7The plant's contacts
17Where do Vietnam's high-protein plant drinks source their pea protein?T10Vinamilk; customs consignee data
18Do Malaysian and Indonesian certifiers accept Vietnamese fermented ingredients as halal?ExportVietnam's national halal centre; a Malaysian certifier

Our rankingBằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc..

Reading.

  • Items 1 and 2 are about rules, and time-sensitive. Each could be settled by one written reply. Together they decide whether most food plays have a clear route.
  • Items 3 to 7 decide the economics of T1, T4 and T5, the three leading plays. They need industry calls, not more desk research.
  • Items 8 to 11 decide how far the security case reaches. Only protein made from domestic inputs reduces import dependence. Items 8 and 9 measure that share. Item 10 is the cheapest step towards a protein balance. Item 11 decides whether swine fever stays a lasting risk.
  • Items 12 to 18 cover testing, cooling costs, regional pilot plants, and routes to Singapore and halal markets.

Other food-security questions that bear on the protein people eat:

  • what share of the fish eaten in Vietnam is wild-caught, as policy cuts the wild catch about 27% by 20301,2Bằng chứng: bằng chứng về Việt Nam (VN-direct); độ tin cậy trung bình: nguồn thứ cấp uy tín, hoặc đọc một phần nguồn gốc. Hướng tới tương lai: dự phóng, kết quả mô hình đã công bố hoặc mục tiêu chính thức.;
  • whether tofu, soy milk and chay sold more during the swine fever waves of 2019 and 2025;
  • whether a food-security policy after 2030 will carry an import or protein indicator;
  • swine fever outbreaks and culls by farm type in 2026;
  • the national stunting rate for children under five in 2025.

30.2 Where sources disagree

Where sources disagree, we give both and state the position we took. These disagreements most affect the report's conclusions:

TopicThe disagreementPosition taken
Protein-ingredient import tonnageVietnam's import data against China's export data for the same tradeChina's data for tonnage, because Vietnam's weights are estimated (Region)
The yield needed for bulk precision fermentation"Above 50 g/L" presented as a calculated thresholdAn expert view, not a modelled figure (Technology fit)
Fermentation cost structure in the regional studyWhether feedstock or capital is the largest cost lineFeedstock is 37% to 56%; labour and power are minor (Region)
Start date of petrol with 10% ethanolJanuary or June 20261 June 2026 (Outlook)
Whether alternative protein reduces disease riskAdvocacy and company authors say yes; peer-reviewed work ties risk to farming, trade and antibiotic use, and no study measures an effectWe make no such claim (Why Vietnam)
Maize eaten as foodFAO and OECD-FAO differ by more than halfFAO, because its items add up: 19% to 23% of protein imported, or 18% to 22% on OECD-FAO (Why Vietnam)
Child stunting, latest year18% in 2023, against 14.8% for 2025 in one press report18% until the national nutrition institute publishes (Protein diet)

30.3 Limits of this report

  • Tools. The general web-search budget ran out early in the first round. After that, we used direct reads of known pages, legal databases, research indexes and trade data. Some sources were out of reach.
  • Language. We read Vietnamese laws and press directly. Vietnamese journals are only partly indexed, so we undercount Vietnamese research (Knowledge and talent).
  • Field data. The retail audit is a convenience sample of 186 products in 11 stores in two cities.
  • Cost estimates. Our cost breakdowns are indicative, not feasibility studies (Economics).
  • No interviews. This report relies on documents. The unknowns above are the agenda for a round of interviews.

30.4 How to help close the gaps

Ministries, starch factories, food makers, fermentation plants, laboratories and investors may hold these answers. If you hold one, please write to AltProtein Vietnam. We will record each correction and date it, so readers can see what has been closed since publication.

Nguồn được trích dẫn trong trang

Các số trong bài dẫn đến danh sách này. Mọi nguồn cũng có trong danh sách nguồn đầy đủ. Danh sách nguồn đầy đủ

  1. NTS-08Prime Minister. Quyết định 339/QĐ-TTg, Chiến lược phát triển thủy sản Việt Nam đến năm 2030, tầm nhìn 2045. 11 Mar 2021
  2. MAC-15NSO. Thuy san Viet Nam quy IV va ca nam 2025: Giu da tang truong, vuot thach thuc, huong toi phat trien ben vung. 8 Jan 2026